📚 學術摘要使用聲明 本頁面收錄論文摘要係依據台灣《著作權法》第 52 條(為學術研究合理使用) 及第 65 條(合理使用四要素判斷)整理。摘要長度不超過 300 字,並附原始來源連結。
若您是著作權人並希望下架此摘要,請來信 [email protected] 我們將於 7 日內處理。原文閱讀請點擊「來源連結」前往原資料庫。
j QE
200712 1-26
\jt
hsV
ww@uhvX
提 要
bqFQn_Ahq@uK —vc}A
e{quLvuDBKJvuvuvB
uvVAH@HKzi
AHVzkNA\H|BvIDbu~
bsvAq@HAHbzVANh
HR~bAbhDsAvB|I
]At@C]AqBDahA
_AHuvPuDvAABzQb@A
tn@AMPh|bpYA
buvPuvxzNqA
buHvyUAhxquLv
uvsVC
關鍵詞:隱逸、隱逸文化、隱逸的自覺、朝隱、文學的自覺、六朝
vdjtUzC
1
j Q E
The Six Dynasties to Live in Seclusion the
Culture Newly to Change
Huang Wei-Lun
Assistant Professor, Department of Literature,
National Kaohsiung Normal University
Abstract
This article is main is discussing the Six Dynasties to live in seclusion the culture to
display newly changes. Then in lives in seclusion in the spiritual contrast from the
Confucianist and Taoism is the discussion beginning, separately leaves two kind of
different living in seclusion condition, and analyzes the Lao-zi, the Zhuang-zi thought to
lives in seclusion the function and its the intrinsic connection which the culture occurs.
The attempt gets rid take backgrounds and so on society, history as the main axle research
viewpoint, but in the individual psychological root, will live in seclusion the behavior to
regard as the life ideal external performance emphatically. The hope can live in seclusion
the cultural research for the Six Dynasties, provides a new inspection viewpoint.
Keywords: Seclusion, Seclusion culture, Self-Consciousness of Seclusion, Zhao yin,
Literature Consciousness, Six Dynasties
2
一、緒論
jHARBgaBUGNOl@ izQMhAoa|HB|hAG]] Nvbyv_LvTAkMOLb lWJRLOCpmOEgnGuuWHuAg 1AoNuUvBu ]jHAhHH|AOHv vHwmvAa^ewhNAhpE^ AOulX{bvROWAlKwVOe@
zQDqAnDC@lXhXWVLvMsQ
2LA
oAoi|phCoO@GvHvC
|@buODiAMH@
AoO@~~AHbzQP~b{EMWA
@PICSOObhFvAzQo{G
@ig@tAMpHAKu{IttAbzQBA
dBShBNzAqtFuvDC]ApG
uJKvOl{zQPLMDAuPvKOzQ
1 ]M^]G mOn ]O_GvXA 79~8^ Aq 41rA 1399C 2 E^G mhvXjNgn ]O_GpgXA 1997~4^ AqjNh _Poir A 39-40C 3
BGVCOHdzlzlKP
DAKWuhHRGvABDG KAOHRA{ FvhFA XHzQASLOAhGOAbH D\aQtAuvNOwuKvDA lqFv PhAO@owA]O@ FMPCMASgLDaNb~Auv GjNAF\At@RqC 3 ---- ------------ ----------- --- --- --- --- AMNh 4F~Hn_oiAhO y AbY{WnhjMH@zCSOOb eNhAIMPBAIAiWGuh vCuveAhiGG@AhF @qDFzABoFhNqMAtAE OeNuhJhvAuv{HoFGAhz MQA]AzLhKFbhWADi BDiPAOuvC --------- --- --- --- --- --- --- H@h ADOhso{P`Aq FhNqMAoOWuhvzbCBA HuvWafNqBAhSOuHvfA \DwRPv[AzLAWBDa sbA}sHBzQX]}NqEeh XHqo@AD uv b uHv A ------- --- --- --- --- --- ---
| 3 dzlG | qHP|XHRGGKPr | | Ams | | En | ]O_G |
| ------ | ------------ | ------- | --- | --- | --- | ---- |
| pgXA | 76~2^ | A 165C | | | | |
4 uv@AisqPUqkAsqk\NHy@AA
HGA]APUCUqkhH
eB{HML{Cuhv AhhIt P_PVAHhDnVeC 4
PuvbuHvC 5 t~AAq@hAKBDAsNO@ HHzQBHDAPAHN VAO@HB@AOA~i{ TNqCHuKvD]]bPIA@wvy AiPlBzQAGXab@_AMbP vi{WA{PC -------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- tAbQhq@uKvc}Ae{ quLv 6uDBKJvuvuvBu ---- ------------- --- --- --- --- --- --- v VABH@HKziA HVzkNA\H BvI~b] Aq@bzVANhHR~bA PXBAItO@@[BH[B[PVA qhAzKO@aHqD ANPgBEpUB~HA@DaHM AsADiQRBWuBpRzQCHb ziWANqBDahA_AHuvPuDv PAABzQbhoiL{Atn@AN Ph bpY[HMA~bu vPuvxzNqAHbuHv
5 ApG uG yz AO@ADwCNASOOe PkAPqQ_{oCvm{n ]O_GsA 73~11^ A 5qQr A 100CMAYquvHDA@u vOuv AiHO{yuv AOHb PD{CG mD —HsbNqn A]nGnHXA 2002 ~1^ A@qDPDr A 9-38C 6 uLv BuvkACXG mlNRn ]O_GA 74~7^ A 172-184CLbuNqvAhOZhuOvyBu OFuSvHibAuLv FhONNqMBO uvAuv C 5
^UAuhv@@hXzC 7 二、儒、道二家隱逸精神的對比 BD@jAbH[B[@[W tAotq@zubzv] innner logic^WAiz ------------ --- --- --- ----------------- --- GBDaUHssb{uhvu 8XF@zQADiADiAbWyzQHAA uv biWXpFP@HA@Aqct@Pz tAinDHspaoDiA@vRB ivRVA[iuBzQBLC ]ANaAO@nDPDwzTAj AnHHMFDahOPAG uAnHH^kMAOHeOuDBwBB vAnuAAvFhuqADlvAn DukMvHu_kvCHApGahO{@GH sbpuzv~wNFDahh{GH MsbpuMvNAeObuHvA {XDnFhOuuvA{XzQQ P_kCOHBDGaPRhDA]Ne{X~
7 uhv@AurNqvRAN^h
uNqvA|ZvyWhHAIApGhBBglBhhBh
BhBBhBBlBHAQdC
8 uuvDOuW@UvHz]b
uzu^ ABv FuhvhOsDWV@UhAHlD VAH@wRYCG mRPRn ]O_G A 83~5^ AQ@quRQjhPVvr A 259-281C 6
BzAPP_C NaAlKBAAWObuDwLDv UApGuwHnAuDCMJF~CU DhALDhCDAhBjA]CLDAIBQjA]Cv 9SG -------------------------- --- --- --- -------- --- uglvIBCDhKALDhihv 10ilbKXB WAxHuDvvAuQ@vOLhAuDvOLA 11A Shb{CAGGuglDKKDhv BDAhuMMvA{uvHwmvzQFBLD AhuM]vAHAXAHKDCSpmyE LlnF@qlcjhHAbqrtF lPUALG ------ --- --- --- --- --- hGBiBBBihBiBhUfBsClGuA dABiBPHvhUfBsGudoAA {AwoIvBihGu~AMAovCvu 12 hOALiLiCv AuAdvOlou`Whv 13AP ------------- --- --- --- ---- --- ]ipelXB[IUzAu]vOFnKDB dAuMvhOuqbvBuvAHqAuu DvAuwLAwHvAHl^lGul]Hv
9 ]Q^`E ]^G myn ]O_GL]vLyGQ~nZQT g`^ AqBKr A 72WC 10 PeA myEFQn A 138WClpqMrgG uDhALDhMv B uDoALDKDv FqrgG uDA\CLDA\A]Cv BuDA MMCLDAM]CvZAObP~b[UAruvi hXBAHGlKBAAWObuD —LDvUC ---------------- --- ------------- --- ------ ------ 11 P 9AmyEFQn A 140U-141WC 12 P 9AmyELlQKn A 166UC 13 myqnuhvqAG uh`Wh]CvP 9A 166UC 7
lDHGuAHAUWFAGv 14AUH
AWRAHF_C AHslAslXBAAhiqL^]A@ AALGuiHKhKAiHhAiH[h[AiHthtAl]KKD @Ahl]Cv]mslE]n^oHMwuiHKBiHv zAbuDvAHLGujHAK]AScDF 15ASGuUDAHDFULDA DAPp]v HDCDHDGH]v 16AislADbuDvbSA ---------- --- --------------- --- --- XBxHuDvPAHlLGujglAphKHv AslKXLhNThALG ------------- --- --- --- --- NTAhTCPqHAN]AhNCIA ]AhhCA]APqHAhNCIA hhCUAAiAjXAgDGu^j DASq]AjgaA^CvPAi]A KwoC 17 ---- --- --- --- --- glKDbugHDAwovAHg_ iAKnP_CYuOALk@itAsl]h BA]nDPwyAGGuLwqAhiHoCGha qAFDCaqAhhovjFFDAGjCjHAo AA[FoA@CahWAFhUv 18@aB FDAgslIAGKF@`ahlihXB
14 myEgn ASmyqn`qG ulv@AHvDH ]CUWFAvUHAWRA_AGAOHH]CvP 9A 129C ----------------- ------ ------------------- --- --- 15 ]~^`E ]^]]G msln]O_GL]vLyGQ~nZQ Tg`^ AqUr A 109UC 16 PeA mslEWn A 243WC 17 P 15AmslEilUnA 223WC 18 P 15AmslEWn A 230UC 8
hC 19 ANDaAmlnLhTA YHHQhQmlEQTnBmlEEnBmlE Q n[A{ZAhbWBfB\Eh QRBBUB@zAHRqu@hRo ALkmlnhzAGBNs 20C ------------- --- --- --- --- mlnAhQhAB]O~HhH PAzAGBfjNCmlEanG ---------------- --- --- --- --- tHAL~ALAUDAhPFULDA hwNFd@AhWFAmATwA` LoAhdI 21 SmlEnG ------ --- --- --- --- jhAD]ADX]ADo ]ARj]CRjGUAh@LFRjaG 22 UAh`AsD]C Xq[AMlh~b[]Ap uLDvB ------------- --- --- --- ----- uRjvAqFuwNvBFu`vAuOuv DaNUAWH^DB^uvAOuB`
19 lhAW]OuDvuSv BuwvLuv AHqgrG uNA wpA{AOaX]AOqaCCLA^SpAAWlJA UhjAOa{~]AOaCKKGgliHdiHqdAp HiHaiHqaCdLAaLCvSqgrG uN ----------------------- --------------- --- --- --- hIQADqhF~oCv 20 Busv AuOMNmlnLawhzAG zmlnhQA@OdABzC@DatDnz @APa AlHNqPjVA`lR AHKBQAhmlnB@zPn@AS tC ------------ ----------- ----- ------- --- 21 ]M^yG mln ]O_GMXA 77~1^ A 421C 22 PeA 555C 9
j Q E
vAuTMAOvAHwBHsuvAG HA~b]AMobOsuCH^u wNvDGu{ZAhVUAwADAP~Ap P@CbAHvFSuhvGuDLDA
R]AwAhjaUCJTMAOAwH ABAZaqvIv CiPuO|A
AoOkVAHmlEnSDG
joADa]ALHqwoCoA
a]CabADR]AlAH]CHAiA
hiCGavAaUAPPAGLw
oCHhhAO[AA]CGAvA
UAmC 23
uovAbDaaAODLB
AoAWiALLfAsAHJAAyu
vA]uoAMojvCpYuNbBimBh
iaaWAoNOFvHqAgF
@UAumvCHbmlnALDOuHv
uMHvADoDAhQaFLHLhApPqgr
GujoDAaAqCDaq]ADwAhaqH
BoCvouQvHAANuBHaMbqgr
A^HUqWGuEtzAVAL
]FKAHFAHFX@AJAp
aNoA^HUvvI
H[BDahkAaXBvDbuDv
A]AbHDwzP|FDahO| uADbpABPjPyAGPDO]|
23 P 21A 558C
10
GhsVw@uhvX
oHqbBoCHbazUABB
vBAOKP@DADKhADhKABuO
vyAuOuhAhvAuOSXXuAvC
qDazAhKBDoADobAuPyCvA
GBDA]uOuPvBPUPMUooiAD a|FBLDAhuwNvA]{kARJAH
LZAWPaC]ANlADahu
vAuObBBBqAObBBBCAqh
]AOvyBkAONMNqAOGo]FHhH
uv@Fzu@C
三、從「人的覺醒」到「隱逸的自覺」
──一個自目的性之隱的內在理據
sFHhAv]tADByB
ATAqyAKAnAJAn
_A[HFvOBAl 24ASB QAbbFPh_AYllu Am@hBRMAN]B kjCpmTEQEKAnKmnYGuAUNA
AnMGyALoCeUZcAkNwHYDAH
qsAAiHGIzGyjHyGzI@A
glHN]CzIA~oIj\jASglA
24 F~DWhQn_DWhAiiCz zAG mQn_Qvn ]O_GvXA 67 ~ 12 ^ ATBT qFvr A 166-218C
11
hK]CBLJA~wAN sAHDKCz@AU Cv 25SmTEQEnGuYAdA[F brA}LdAOHvA]mQKnyGuG{ACAZJAWvIDAe @A_adAAGlwVAhUiTJABPkb] AZdAgRG]CAdAngAHLCmnG yzAjCAi]FAD]Cv 26oOlL`A -------------- --- --- --- -------- --- ]OlJRds]pGXK@OiR^C]AAK BAE\hlAPAHdAujNAAD@ 27Ao@HAAEqH^av ANBv @VFHAh@AqmAsAD AprC ---- --- --- --- --- --- uOAshHh~b]iAM@~b]A izAo@wRaF~Hn_hA HD@hquKJhvuvA A]AFWz~b]~A bOiCAE^ ]NhhtFv]AWhj@ADbJ C\F~lAwoiXsPA{hAKO HDquvvXzPRCA~@QA{ AMHAChAwWCz @bOB@uhj@EMAO@HH HaAHUv 28AHAKNmuH ------ --- ---------- --- --- ---
25 ]^E ]n^pQ`G mTn ]O_GxXA 73~8^ AmQ Q@EKAn A 336C 26 PeA mQQGEn A 378-380C 27 ]n^SE ]^`G m~n ]O_GA 76 ~ 1 ^ AQ TBqPBB}BBOC QTr A 1747C 28 E^G uO[A~@QTMHAQHUhj 12
vUA[HC G \Z@NN A@SAPL@N~PCKK Qn_T~NQAiH@AuHvO w。29 AuvYN@@WSsb sbAO@PqYWP _NqMC ----- --- --- --- --- --- --- ~Q@qAFZBgHHH NIAbbaF@BPHos AsNBsBPsbNqvtCOqgB cBHU_wXoAqBB P}lAHVlsAXo{BCq zL@b}iAEEoFHDPsfA\ ~bB[@ATAH RM hAO{bVAEe{@~OHMAC ibs@vbNWAbH~ AbHB@{@gBSWBFv@ANt @@PbpzCBbuvNP A FHVOnhFX@A@@WSsbBn lsbNqRDC -------- --- --- --- --- --- --- ]AF~HAh PhAA b]iAuvAYOAHHPA
hAj@pOFAiHLov AP 2Aq~hs Psr A 255C 29 pG mn ]O_GOWL]A 76~10O 14^ A 6qQMr A 149-150CSpApG uqF~~QAoNAsYs @[H[AMMbXWP@SxAOOHAoNOH v Cm{n AP 5A 5qQr A 87C --- ---- ----- ---- ------ --- --- 13
uOb[kAH@BHOAbz
YVA\HHjNqMANOLApLmAHZ
E^AAnP@HAP[Au
v\qaDwBzhwHDApE^
hHGvHQ@AishoAH|t@
aAi@zQMlDVHRwy 30C ~A@\HHWRPHA MbWANuvAqN[UBpHB XA}FuHNv^A}Fu NNvVAquFuv}XAi}Fut vsVAHPF@AsaB hWqBpM` 31COHANApG H ------- ---------------- --- ------------ --- --- --- uv 32DOXFuJVjv[AWaP oAF~HAhquKJhvaAVFuD vsaAhAOK~JBAORzQA ouKvc}AHhNqPswApG NuHvBuvN[V _kzAhhsVAiWuhvC --------------- --- --- --- --- --- ---
30 ]pAHbphDWAq~bhu{HvJAO
lDauvVJA{HHozAH
`JBushCSpE^G ujhjAv AGohCvvo{AyBPLA b@C_haoHN]CvP 2Aq~hsPsr A ----------------------- ----------- --------- --- --------- --------- ---- 255CtAjuhHAuOblDYHWVswv A uvOYVCjA qPDr Amjn A T@A 1992~A 140C 31 N[BPoityAG mQDsn ]O_G OWA 2006~7^ C 32 G qQPsYr@Am n A 1995~G^ A 501-529C 14
四、東漢至南北朝的「自足性分之隱」
QhqF~_AO]HAhAyq
| sAt@||AnOAbouqvWhoi | | | | | | | | | 33AX{ | |
| ------------------- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | ----- | --- |
FuvAm~EhnbRhAK@@F
zAG GuQqjovCvSGuJA CvOHh A}oFZoAtCHAycA yAPP@C~HDA^HDARvH AhMHwAUHAHEMCM[ aA WAZLvAw 。34 ---------- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---- --- uvAoNhb@F`oANH AAuO~b]AOVFG_kAO ujVA]bo_BAAOK~N BAnNqAOlD@pvHA{AO @H[@g_AhEo\uKvceAoWa MC ouvAbqhrY }aDAuhMHADaQHAwgLyz DAuOhhAnhNPDzvASuo
33 uqvWhAiHqvApm~Ehn BmEhn BmEhn B mnEhn BmEBhn BmQEhhnm@syEhgnO At~AiqQhgAMXuhvpApNB ACXu] AODhhvNCGYRq_\r Bq --------------------- ------- ------------- --- ------ --- ----- ----- ------ ---- --- qr Bq qr BUqKr B]qUKr Bjqur BqUr lpRdmthn Bjmhn Bmhhn Bimhn Bxmhn mlnqQr BqhrgAiMhC\RG qQ H~@sGhr AmZZn 24B 4A ] 87~10^ A 7C 34 P 27AKQTB qhCCQTr A 2755C 15
HO{hNO|AO@XGMpHA]
]CHStM{NABnNP{LFs
35CA
sRQ]SFAuaUFlDAWv
uhhvBuStM{NvBuhN
PDzvAPzFhw}lXuKvcA
FquLvVuvsVAoOhV_kA
P]OhTC m@syEnTGODGulFsAYRiA wAlNqC_HAyzCHGy SWypzA@GHzYCqbAnGy GBhAXhpCz\CGyqxLD cA Czv 36SpqhrGuSbFsAMLA` ---------- --- ------------------ --- --- --- hCHHkxAkxG ygddAjHAHLHzv 37bohrA@hHBpXBBAtHP_F@ hLhAddAihbhjANO B OHQABObAL~bAunuhvB AoNXGHzQABpBoNBbC ----------------- --- --- --- --- --- loHaLhADvAHAwib~ qrAVAm~nAulAA pAHgvASGHZCAHWAW `sAHAuCAiHTAR~MmAHAG -------------------- --- --- --- --- --- KK]bACLAMAlDAUA ECR UAkWCwAFIlMADHC PFlADAGAHCunAoM
35 G mjvn ]_G_jXA 1986~1^ Aqhr A 176-195C 36 EG m@syn ]O_GRA 73~10^ A 803-804C 37 PeA 654C 16
GhsVw@uhvX
Cn@@WADEaCdAORCpOA
hiH]AXtzoCZrJvI
[qrudAORvBuvBuDH
vBu@@WADEavBuZrJvvAGN
tFqFBBp@@Ar}JyA
o@XBBAAxH[PP_AMi
@HAAoFhAOtbAON
PAHYHUCPo@]OPsLhA
@aAuASvAVDaAuBp
vvC
SpwDqCrG
HbWAzAHVAHAiFRAH
PAG_sAAHjAHAE
AR@AwoNsAAmAUAlCHjC
Ae_O|AHOMAvu]CKKMpsL
AD{kHwAAHlMAAeiEQAA
CpHAoAHACAOAAOH
GMyA^AHQAAhFy@_O
oC38
qrsLAOFkHwAAOFulMA
AeiEQvADb@AOnAonLA
NbuAvAHuHAovAOAAnqb
uvXAHuOMvBuvuvApPmlEgn
upaNoA^HUvvCOHAoADO
AOhAOtbowAObkA
38 ]M^YiG mWjTNTn ]O_G@A 712^ AUA m
E@TQCEfn A 3-4C
17
ODBKJAONPC
[vApmEhnGVAKAnqmn BmnA
jq@As~DATDCSmnqlrBqqrA
MGu^wIphAQpApvAEvNAPPn
_VyCWsA 39CSYZuADGu wA_~ChGAGvI] 2762^EbsLAJQ sAH~AAu^HTAe@hA qHGQ H@ C ] 2765^t@hODABHGuO@AEYOUGvAe hDGuE[_LWAoFe`WUAioJC AH_]CBUoJwAUDO]Cv] 2776^ SmEhnG@]uJhDgvAGuj HAFATOxAaOavAuJP@HsuvC ] 2426^OBx AhAnsAAsPhC] 2447^g ]nAnsAuAYMoC] 2451^CmEh nB KAnsA~sC] 2285^Sgpvh @AqPlrvGunAAGbXAwh NCv] 2293^mEBhnBc~DACCLAAHs ----- ---------------------- --- --- yTwC] 748^ ApmQEhhnGjjAp`AH@gAEM A KAHCC] 1929^gGMbALNKAs~A -------- --- ----------------- --- P{w~AAjASRsAoAC] 1931^ gRsA ATA@mhnAqGuPA QLCG~pA@ORnCGNgAWICiA HCMEAMYCv ] 1937^OGe{NACxA --------- --- --- -------------- ngvAMNAnLAtAWBHMAHA@
| 39 ]n^SE | ]^`G | m~n AP | 27A 2758CUxGQ| |
| --------- | ---- | ------ | -------------- |
| vAAXAAt[C | | | |
| | | 18 | |
GhsVw@uhvX
UC] 1939^HvaGujhACAKKD
MwAEvHvZAlAHQ@~
JRABHhA]OFkwAOHt
@oBbaiNaCCAPo]OBuM
VP^kC
mlEgnGlAjehF@HFe
UAlDUAGu^DtAwTdoAy
qWCtAdQGHGHv\o
@AHAODaHVhAbK
@`hAHeB_YGuHHHvA_YK
HGuLHHALHGRALHoWCuAOuvA]
BDahPA@bNHDwBzA@b[iBO
sEuAHHzQlDEeXPAoO@R
AP]OH@shbuKvD
zA{bhWKX@HBVAB
]hoi{X@quLvuvsVC
五、朝隱:一種「言意說」、「跡冥論」的隱逸化體現
hoiAFWzuvVA@S{HN
OuvX{CuvAiq[HG@G
MqhAX{AOhoWNqM
AA]pLgL@uvAhu
dbShAhuvJtAKLkPuv
FSHuSvALDO]jDKJAOuvN
19
uvApYqiA]NLsFCGG@kADP
hHAAoAANFbalQs
C
mEHTnG ]T^HWAPnBxBnpB PA{p@ RC{vRpTOrATnAD_lCxB GuDsAhAMACvTG uUiCDAiAiCb AbCv] 2151^ JMHQbZEhA]unoNAioBoA uOeAbovAHhwnPsAAiAi A]oNADbDbABdqrDGup Ajv ANLuUAeuOU upv A --- ---------- --- --- ----- NAAw~OujvApPU@mKnHBuA 40AO XHA]DLAHuAXBPkv@ oz@gAEHyVAhnC HmEBhnRhAAONuUKAHW UA~HDAB\Cjv] 731^kC ------------ --- --- ------ ---
Msouv]ANYAiqhH{uh
Wv]mERn^AR|uvBuqvBuJ
oPjASoytxv 41HA [H[ALzoA`hNBRoAzzAN n^atMuMvPuWvolsq[HzC
| 40 m@syE|n | 91AP 33A | 270C | | |
| ------------ | -------- | ----------- | --- | --- |
| 41 vjQhHAAYG | | u]L^QIRjPpA | | |
QtM@X_AfJ@`AoHnSWhnAC
txSeUAX@SJ@CX@AOMWFJ@AOMWCvm
PQhHAn ]O_GvXA 81~11^ A 266C 20
GhsVw@uhvX
pHmlEpCnuhgsAHjv@qG
HYtH]CtHbqWAMLsLA@
ZvI{AAKHoFstAP
AKH|oFZvIwHH
。42
sAN@LAGDU
usLvLuqvAYOFKBAtHHy
AMAYAPLAHA@H
BBstBPbuvAuLsLv
buvA]uvBuvE_IAiObHAbuv
PbuvoOXAHLSGuzAA
CP]FC~]CGtHC~HA LHAGLAUHMYCv 43bHk AtHHuC~vAbuLHvA]uLv
HMAUuUAv]qFr^AHHu LG]v]qr^BuHAL]v
]qpCr^AJMuLvHAM]|A PBP]qrGGLP^AOB{A
uvBuvLAusLvPuqvO]NbuLv[U@
C ]ANzhADaHDAB h[IAAtXWuoNvBuvAONbKB AFuvAGuBCAJkN
42 P 21A 28CSvTqG uYUHHyt HLz CtHuOyz A yHz CybqALsLz CbsLA{qCAC Hyz CM@H{AzHAG}tHAU@~HC yUAz]CvmPzn ]O_GA 78~10^ A 190C ---------- --------- --- --------- --- 43 H`qjvvr uCAC]vyAP 21A 268C 21
bCv 44AJHASHpAqAv`Lh
WFBLuUAALApPbqwrG
uALSqYCIPAg~CTiaT|A
JhCKKXBAHQCuCAwHhhA
YgliooCv 45AhPXKALABo@A R uhWvlAKbqALsLA 46WA Bou~xLxxABLv@kAJiouv SiuA_OeNAtFAPW AOhjKqAPF yC ------------ --- --- --- --- --- --- 六、結論 `AhblOwKDoASOObjNuKv 47 UAliuvuvAuveS hPuKvHuKvAa_ASH` huDv ~AOlGqN`OXKJRAoD[
44 v^yA]^G mnvn]UG^]O_GA 74~3^ A Q@ACTQ@qvr A 1038C 45 P 35A]UC^AmEQCEn A 6UC 46 pmRnPQLDwUM`AG uLAFBx qAF^GAmFCv~UDsG moivXQn_ n ]_GHXA 1988~4^ AqpRr A 183-207C 47 zjNuKvG ulLG yKuhAuhKCzKP AuiHJKAKuiAKqAblAHMC G yKA]CzONAKQCQbAeASL gs AArCGDKAKSA jNKq]CvG m~hXqFvvBQvnxWjv ----------- ---------- -------- ---------------- --- ----------- --- shA 82~ATqlh[r A 44CjNhh_ WPAhE^G mhvXjNgn AP 2AqjNh_P oirA 1-92C 22
zQ][HLk{AuvD|aAo]
NOhePCUe~Qn_@qA|
ZAL`aA_HvvAoFv^hAo
sBPJ{AEolobu@vpUAs
vB@AC 48A[HNAawH HAgILAAZAPlosv RNqMzQBAOLHAD~VBnBv@ KBtBi@A@auvHwmvBN ~BRA@DaQRBWuBlDp RA@H[A]OPhquKJhvBu v@uvBuvbzAB] ohbDaHAoFzBATFWaBo{F nNqPC
Oi}AhDqKcUXAXFa|BDw
AiFDaaFXFNqBAiFu
vzQaCSuvX{Ab@@A
{NDOQhHlDzQHA@zcA
|utHbqWALsLvDiAAHuoNvB
48 QlJAKL@qzALG uQWhD
{xPWeG@Om|PhbzP{QpWP APP{OPaLFt@OHNVzQP{o
PCQPMzALimXIDaWzAHW@U zAzPaPtzPHzCLbo@VWAMRA@ AWV@ULA^kl~RAb@Nxvo{X MRMuCiObt@ALS@P@URwipPAOL
LkhNoSo{@C]ADaWzPaQ@A
XQWhRhGzcCvG m~Qvn ]O_GnqA 2002~1^ A 3-24CA]{]ouGzcv A~Pl buKXvDW]A Bq@bzA XBDO@B DuGzcvbhP{C 23
uvzAjuXBPkvHuC~v 49AO XoAQoNAAqiAiAj ApAJWASiApCBuv@g TAxuhQoiAiwFApAUNhQA jWdCihQydz] paradigms^~w ------------ --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ------------ --- AQ[ibNMoyzvC 50 AASi[HNOAYNhP{AAFiB @F~BMFJkBNbCFPPB 迹CPA~ASuRvuv 51CAL ------------ --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----- --- {hAYDhAhhOR@ ABbhhL{AMwt@MOD AOlDA]ObYH[B@[H [{UAi{RCOHh{HAl bzANP_AhPAiAo AuuNqvAnObItAo]
49 H`qjvvr uHAHv@yAG uPAC~]CWC~H AMAUDADH]CvG u AmMLhAL]CJOi]OAYuYAC~A AiH_C~PAMHaAMnHAhMAU AphDiAoOHMCvmHn ]O_GA -------------------- ---------------- ----------------------- ---------------- --- ------------ ----- ------ ------ ------- 88~9^ AQ@qWPr A 308C 50 B`G qKPXFvr@AmsEQg@n ]O_G pgXA 78~8^ A 323C 51 mDnOG uHNwPhAv@WLADxj@]@A }AOAhAHWyRz vA]^G mn ]O_G A 68~2^ A 99BC 69A 2593-2594Cuv AmsOnD Jmn Gu] c^~AHsABnGsAHCv ]^G msOn ]O_GsA 62~11^ AqGDcr A 931CS msDhnG uMQ{AWAHSKCDAnBC K~ A `jCv]^G msn ]O_GA 196BC 121A 5596COvhqAHWAhLOa\ Qn ASpX^bq_srueoADnv 24
ODNEJbAHNhuvAsOF
YbAONWNqMA]NOAb
RhAohOuLvOu
vAO@auvvAODa
uv 52AMOzhbDnuCAouv
u 迹vkiAOszAP]{Fh
| buvBuoNvH|UAqu | | | | | 迹vuv | |
| -------------- | --- | --- | --- | ------ | ---- | --- |
| vAlDBHoBu | | | | 迹IvoiC | | |
]AhsVAObh{HH_Ie
UAqLBDahAAhqDBKJA
VBAB@w]kNVA
LDNObsjNlKBDA\H|B
vIb]iRAqhbzBqI
[zANm@[BH[B[hW[HAoO
Vz 53A]OVzzAib@ OAXQuhVvtn@CBA
52 uvvuv AsB[G{G uahDOvAOv wv BuDahHF`BAqHAnDv Cqhr A me_zujn ] ^ A2007~11A 74-77C 53 bRuvo@ANOu{HvPuvVA u{HvO@gsbAuvhIMDA iHQyzuNvuv CPAbsAhON ---------- --- --------- --- --- --- --- {H@ONGC@nDAYO@NAPN YMwPAGYbg@@wHC]ADA iPAG@OH{HDA]@ghsFt@hH DA]qAeXDgAhX CG mnqn ]GjXA 2000~2^ A@B ]1^ ------- ---------- ------- --- ------- --- --- qP{Hr A 1-7CuVzv AYOh @@uvVsA Nqh{HJA ob{HIzA H@O~bvB IAhSxvN qC 25
j Q E
uVvADO@AO@NquLvA
@uvA]O@|A]
Ao@uVvSxYbhWaoBWNqs
wAHApG|A\pHB[O
@uv AhgonNqAiO@u
hvAoiOuHvNAbPW@P
i{AOuHvPFuvAuv]{F
^C
26
校對記錄 ID: paper:ebc054c9eb34 · 最後更新:2026/5/8· 版本:20260508 · 版本歷史
其他資料:學術論文(個別著作權)、本派傳承(CC0 1.0)。