文化人類學／宗教人類學理論與儀式研究講義

n

j

sh

U

s

s GL@

G}h

EQG~

KnG

HQUJIAzLdBDX

vmmgCsF|G@BA

L{cCGBA|PH

UCTBU]NqtRAHAU

]sbNqC|BcH`[C

gA@A]Ast_BsB

m^UCGskAsy{siCT

zUAL{B

TPWxB~HD``BzC|

eRAcRB\RBq[RB

RA`hNqtC

ASIMSC

rGBsBUB

PBDnBu

Us

@

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

.1 @`

sI

.… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

1

G`

T`

ss

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

.3 m^U

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

.5 G

sk

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

12

@`

sy{

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

12

G`

T`

|`

`

`

s

sBJ

sH

kHMD

}zD

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

13

… … … … … … … … …

… … … … … … … … … … …

23

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

27

… … … … … … … … …

29

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

33

T

U

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

34

@`

L{

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

34

G`

T`

|`

`

P

WxPT

DL

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

46

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

55

… … … … … … … … … …

… … … … …57

… … … … … … … … … …

61

`

D``Bz

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

63

|

R

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

65

@`

c

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

65

G`

T`

|`

\R

q[R

R

@`

SI

G`

S

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

69

… … … … … … … … … … … … …

74

… … … … … … … … … … …

82

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

…88

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

88

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

90

m

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

..93

@]u^

G]^

T]a^

|]^

]Da~m^

]^

C]]I^

K]^

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

..98

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

..99

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

100

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

101

… … … … … … … … … … … …

…104

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

105

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

125

… … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … … …

129

@

@`

sI

q~XyBhqjWUZU

QlOAiHXDAb`T|v

_CHAHkA_w`DANAOHZv

AsAYXHDVVC

bUUyeAUQAjhj

NUxWa~UsC

bjNUsAijysMUN

sG@Oj

ysG}mhJi`

snB_zmmOnAgPmDAgn

YnBRmaQsnBL^mqjNRz

[H

<<O >>D{NnBL^mANqnC

GOUNsGi@mNhfHUsnBi

OmNsnBimvnBRmnBl

mMUnC

bxWa~UsAiOUsPa

U

sG@OOUsG}mOW

`snBSmOWUnBmxWUnB

yLmxWa{UsinCGOaUsG

MmxaU

UsnByAmU

snBJgmaBsnB^muaUv

XX qmtnBm

--F

1

C

WziAjyPxWa~Fs

xB`JsC

OAaWsAous

PyApLmCqOnmCqOgnBBa

BsmFmxnBsFXmsxnA|B

Mas`JQC

2

AH~

G`

ss

BsG

PsgogmUsnOi]A@O

s]AGOmUsnsC

@Bs]G

sOHAqpjL\hAoh

LH`AbW\hCBal]aBj

psYAH@^bC

FAF~{AqU@bAoqL

{gAFUh{QkAA[W~O

iUiUAwsMC

GBUsBG

ospqAnWLTQAHfCEdHA

_xWq@opAuxWnwC

pGHo[IAN|

PxWnBatAotYO

FPnBatOC

bjasyUAu@M`xWqUsa

sAtAsGWN|C

LBsG

szLm`BaP[Xo

zRAFHUDG

@BAL{cC

aWSCWSO

3

GBA|PHUC

TBU]NqtRAHAU]sb

NqC

|BcH`[C

4

T`

m^U

uvsbvHsO@Q`DA@

@`JQAiHFotz[BHtB|

HvOYCp]

Interpretation Of Culturesn@{A@iHMX@

GeertzA 1926~^bm The

|At@

MAH]

{X|Oq]

Clifford GeertzA 1999A 165-169^C

Edward B TylorA 1832-1917^B pA]

Sir James George

FrazerA 1854~1941^ AlszhAC

\zDqDqvTUALslAN

`NObPwAtikhAHF

sC\F]

Emile DurkheimA 1858-1917^AL{

OHs

xAUOWSBiALkkhA

OHD[RkARbNqBHx]

Fbvm

FXAO|cxAF|

HatchA 1981A 221-227^C\

The Elementary Forms Of The Religious Lifen@

] social fact^] DurkheimA 1992A 409-416^CyA\Fv|

sANu|vqHzh|hzA

s~zNqtoiC

HasjPW\FB]

jtvTC\FHA[IA{OHsx

APHnAHnB^mAJvqA

o

Max WeberA 1864-1920^

OtHO@LQqN]

HatchA 1981A 191-202^CP

HA{HQqP{F|XGnDH

AjtO]

HatchA 1981A 21-27^CO]\FH

5

[Ih

AFhus~|C``vTNHC\F

[[ID[[Ijs~|sH|A[[Ii]GR

\RAD[[ID[RkC]GROQ|A

Nb|@QA~iHo{Hb]C\F|

um

The Division Of Labor In SocietynDAMPP|

SOsasYA@|MP

]C\ROo{@|{H[~C\FsDwg

o{Ao|ALNHsH

|PAoFwCX\F\s~|C\FX

[R|ASOhh

OWDA@htC]GP\

u|FARA{HqbD[

h[IC]A\FXD[RkAskHxNq

[@QAD[Rk]tHxDq[DqjhC\FQ

HxQ

QkA@OcAYeX@Hxtbc

CA@O|cAN|cUHxAYzWNHxt

@hmu]

B MorrisA 1996A 124-130F HatchA 1981A 206-227^C

A\F]GRskvTNHanFA

Nb|@QF\RskoFc\jvJ

]

A.R.Radcliffe-BrownA 1881-1955^s~|FD[Rsk

FHat@[l

|AZdz

] E. E. Evans-PrichardA 1902-1973^S]

Victor W.TurnerA 1920~^Bv

]

Claude Levi-StraussA 1908~^vTC

BHvsjvTbkWALjH{H

sA]qH[I{HA~o{Mw]AHsJINq

t`AAL{{H@v]GNFo{H

6

A]]GYuO{HI]wCo[IDnw

ub

AkvukvAH@PVOAhAD

{HYubv]AqA

1994A 8-9^CMBbH

vTO\FjAO}FH{HssCA

BNHvsHxRA@NAW@]

AqA 1994A 9-12^C

vHsWijsVA@OH|[

sbAN@|PM@|[sbO

qAN\JM

AN@sDAsUUWSCND

ZdzMHxSBCoskUuAN

NXs~uI@sAFCoF

suUvRs~|C

sHhA[WOALkHa

z[IXA]Aos`X[I@nzC

Durkheim

R.Hertz F@O[

] 1^]

Bronislaw Kasper MalinowskiA 1884-1942^

X

injJ]

Cracow^ADASbw

jH]

A\Fph]

Karl Bucher^zAbd}fb

Sir J.Frazer^Kgm

The Golden Boughn`PA

NMwVHC@HTn^mG@ONH

kTCh

1.uA{Nx

MC

2.vm}nu@UAYONvgH@_

C

3.BSkYOpmkC

nPRCBqHwtagPN

ygRCTOszcAHWOPAH

GOx

7

AzAHUDtO]zA

178-185^CzHP\Fjh]

1858-1942^bHA[ItCH{AH

Dn]MBPXOPVCoXOPVO

1992A

Franz BoasA

AFHAql]

HatchA 1981A 302-310^C

RHAX]A@OQAHTuUDOh

hNpL{AYOqTuUoQqCGOVA

DH{]

HatchA 1981A 316-325^CNHaq\

]

functionalism^jvAYX\j^mCMA

@]PtjwqAjPiTG@OX

AN\UlYCGO\QDqA

N\

ANOjsbPCTO

\QDqAN\OHDPQqCXP

\QDq\wqPHtjAHLkoiA

\QDqPHM@PAcDnzAvTNH

aC

H[IAR\s~|Aosq

aaPR\C

] 2^J]

A.R.Radcliffe- BrownA 1881-1955^

X^A~]

W.H.R.Rivers^AQ

] W.H.R.Rivers^B]

A.Haddon^B\F]

Emile Durkheim^B

] H.Spencer^HvTAHLc]

Structural- functionalism^j

vCQoiivB\B\TqC

bvAQooiikhAPQ

Cb\A]\FyvTAs|

8

WAoQW{bsmwFH]

CgDGu@l|CUPHb|Wt

YMwAp@Cxb@tY

The Andaman Islanders^n

@]

HatchA 1981A 240-241^CvOAbgmwFHn@A

\QAX{bLCF\A

~Nb\RWAXSw\DAF

@\WRA]oiX|c[C{AHAnq

L|c\ADqL

[I{|WULUP\AO

@NO|E|C

Hj|QP\sVAMP

XqH[IQ\tjAOoPs~A

Hi\sC

]

HatchA 1981A 239-250^C

] 3^ZI]

Arnold Van GennepA 1873-1957^

ZIXAkA\FP@CLN^

mb

1908 XFmqL

]

The Rites of Passage^n@AH

AHFX[HAN

1. ]

rites

of separation^ 2.L]

rites of trantion^ 3.X]

rites of incorporation^

TCGAAbbWApbB

hvCLGsAAPHH

xm|~Ag`uYTPCXGL@s

aA

AsxA@Noq]

283-284^CMZINBLBXTAOo

T|PX{P@qLABX{@wLX

AiXXPCSB

B MorrisA 1996A

9

Chapple

Coon ZIqLX@kAS{ZIL

@SxG

Asis`C

4.@q`jC

1.NAsiC

2.Q

3.iHAAUWdBq

C

5.jbv]

B MorrisA 1996A

290-291^C Chapple P Coon X[j[IA{FZ

IbqLjOHa~A[js

YCEA]ZIqLX@kG

PV@AWb@RAOwXL

AB@RL{NO@LC

MXA@Rq}lH

3. jROq@wMat@PwMa

AMR]iqwMaHwMaOq

HwMawMaC

ALPDYH|]|]ZA

sZIqLzAUU`@k

RAFC

1. NL

2.Lsb

O@LC

4.bRAuHo

1996A 26-27^C

] 4^S]

Victor W TurnerA 1920~^

SA@HxjvAH^mb

HxHsM

RAbsW`]

liminality^Bt]

marginality^B

] communnita^rOLyCSqS

GluckmanA`b|c\sAP\O\

PAm@Dw|P]

Schism and Continuity in an African

Socity^nOLoN@AMo]OS}lNsPH

xWCSHxzjPiTIG@IAHxu@

EXF\hMXA[\hPTCG

10

YvC

IACHxNqC@AMzAPH@

PgA]_BPAMlOCt@A

hO|hAP|c]tWdBA|

WdolO]

B MorrisA 1996A 277-279^CTIAwBHxNqnp

hASXThkG@OgaHBHxA]A

MaMqHALoNqCGOg[

HxpQ|B@BhNqCTOg[RHxb

mhNq]AA

bS]

Victor W Turner^HxzUAgs`SXT

RM

1992A 357-395^C

hMNqkAHxNq`JFCs

MHxNqkG@OsaPL

{A[WHBBlAo{tHxNqC

GOsaMaPL~AbL

HxNqC

11

G

sk

@`

sy{G

sMskAssy{pUG

m`z

x

y

aP[

L

{BTPWxBH

m

X

QD|MP

LH

sR

sR

sR

H Arnold Van Gennep

OH

Malinowski

Victor W Turner [

qLzR

c

Radcliffe -Brown [

IR

\

IAN

BBTBBH

HxNqR

g

12

2001A 11-13^CiOs

G`

s

Bsdw

gsHjh@wdhA@OsaIFGOv

HC

@BsaIG

O@sAHFFvTUL{

HxNqP\Cz@sAod]

AFnqB_qBFqBqBFqTQ@pqA

`nGQEI]sFA

odAOHnq@DndaAzG

]@^BnqOsF

baAFcAiO

CqFvBgPC

]G^BnqHfdHA`HfTGjACq

@jqC

]T^BquHfAgLQhEpAw

UUqAUwqALtC

]|^BaXUq~UyAo

SC

]^BqmsxnBLmCqOnmCqO

gnBmFmxniAUqH|

OpPC

G BvH

sHHhAvTdsHUQJIA

~vHBDvTAhWbgQ

13

CboyHzOHjxFHQAAX

jLQBoDQd~vaQ

@XvC

LBsaIaM[PH[

saM[PH[yzG

mCqOnmCqOgn

Cqoivn@

NQ|

soin

4.q[azBeUN|@m

SwHBvEdsH^P@tn

5.sFXmsn

FeUxjaztLTaaa@dAma

ad`qpnCHW@XkzG

pUG

@BaM[G

]@^azm

1.L

2.s||]Xm

3.s||]Xmv

6.mn

7.s

Cq_nGQQGQ|Q|AFg

Q@@G

O TQ@AF_qYGFAFg@G

@@E

O

GQAnFqLbGnA_nGQQAn

qzFAFg@@EQ@A_Fq_A_nGQ

QKQAUqQ|@CxWl_A{

fBsfWAFZ@@Q|@]FEQ@^AnZ

@QG@APZ@KQ@APjjAHnq

AP_tbqjEdQAnm]sFA

1986A 77-78FSFHA

1999A 306-308^C

j_eACqTAOsn]n

^B_]_^BjBpBnFF]F^BBGq

14

]q^FF]F^B]^A

Oq|QG~@FvB|BBNBsBCPqA{b

CqnB_BFBBFBBGqBnq

QECCq`nGQKIKAnQI||

jA_]tnBGqBjBp^CI

]t^|IAGIGsAFGIK

TALq]L~^@IKK]LA

261-263^C

]G^aa

UqN^cAahy

stXSCb^APpIJe

JPCahOH@O@vTA

^Ae{kPq{H]sFA

nqP_qO

^P^{cAaheCF

sqAahe]BWuA

24-25^C

Cqa^a@UAahe{C_APjjpp

aP`DCsqH_qWsBzsAEQAZ

aunsB_]g^BUaCUq

qeTABhayJAHqWXGetC

iaaSj

h

a

n

_

^LlgAg

^lgC

gDC

@T|AF

1991A

1986A 78-81^C

1999A

Uh

^DC

^DC

15

FB

Hg}HCghp

0

Dn^{A`zoFC

4 kCg[C

8500

1 ~eC

F

ghDnAp

0

1.5

^Aa

1.5

6.0

}HC

kCCg[CaU

ghKHgA

hg[C

ghDnHgAghp

ph^A`zoFC

0

4 kAC

g[C

1974^

G]

]T^

aavAqW`uvTAqWL

sAnAKLhBAVBHNC

Cq|{AvujAKLjnnAV

jF_B__CpAQ~eCtC|

I@HWAtQ@tFCKI@Ajt

FCGQI]sFA

CujvTu`Wt

~AHKAGQCA

TQITACGQ|IECVF_uIZA

~CAH@NAKIEA

QIEACCI|]sFA

QKIC

~Bq@ds|QKIGADnb|Qnu

MaKBALhBA~Bq]s

FA

1986A 95-98^C

1986A 85-88^C

ALunujA

1986A 89-94^A~

16

]|^

qB

qiBBBBTG

1. qG

nqB_qBFqBFqqqAW]]m

O]AqW~PT@NBuC

2. qG

iUqqMPxWqAbUq

qWAHnqAno}UqAOLUqhS

aqBCn_|@CKAnFTQ@C

@AnQ@C@CqquHDAa

pCbPxW

qWAxxx@

PxWaBuCx@AxjCQ@C

3. q

Dn@xWPqBAeua@aACKZC

GBaH[G

]@^aW

qWnACqHuvWAlNCA

ZD{qFL@kqQAQAAC

]AU~AC]XJADMAt

nqCmPApqAYZcALuvA

C

{AiuvAMCFuvANu

vuvA@Cq`W]sFA

]G^}ov

LEPHvwavoiAi|qGq~

}oq]QE@^BOWv]QE@G

1986A 71-72^C

Q@Wb^B{Nxnuaeu]

1949-1992^Bxav

17

q]

1992 ~H^]LEBHvwA

1999A 150-154^C

1. q~}oq]QE@^

mCqOgn

GNAfK~TAb[

1994A 66-67^C

}PA~vqqAtiqAYO

nB_qlI]LA

b_AsBu~AwAsqA

NAwOEAcC]uFIZAT

EaFAEqW~aAq@FEaA

y~TahSEqWAASOK

FCMFYGAIYFTFAXq~E

qW]}apAdAMwg_xWAOT~UqA

MMUTOEUqWApA]u

o{{Cqy~}lAHoBsUqA}aF~

A~JsCAyQ|~hsAwO

HALXCaAEA

w}o]i~A

1999A 270-279^C

ogBBBM|N}AwHw~A

Aqb~MfC

2.OWv]QE@GQ@Wb^

HAF]Q}o}lCFbn]Q

AHKoi~ASbnB_BFB]QA]sIZA}

o~CObGQ|~OsAb_]pOAb

AxAQ]m]BWA

28^C

3.{Nxnuaeu]

TQKAjuAxhxWAinUqAbn

1949-1992^ .

18

aAN

1999A

B]mA

{fU

F

]nB_FFbF

@@eAP~QGA]FpC

|QG~AFpF_pATAsF

]nAF]FAF]FC

|Q|~AF_p@FMpC

|Q~AaFAM@FMpA

aFe|AIxF@zANBs]B

WA

1999A 28^C

4.xavq]

1992 ~H^

KQ@~YAAIaFAxA

QT~aFvAFA}lavAX@

]BWA

1999^C

]T^y

~OqfuJ]HBsB

D^AiQAayuHyt

PCbmn@NyPB

jASF]H{N^Bn]Hu{

N^BZP]HZ^B_]H^N^B

]HwN^AFin

yA]A{BBsBQGF_{fy

A]AwBwBPCC]iA~F

]A

1994A 49-52^C

iHfpj

a

Hf]^

~FBn_BFC

`HfKQC

19

nzF~UqC

_J@aC

~UqC

~UqC

~UqC

~UqC

1986^

`HfQC

`HfTC

`HfGC

`Hf@C

`Hf@C

`HfTC

Gy

s

nyt

{

M

Z

Lf

Gsx]

]|^vH

|O@|A~DnuBsB

TDAHDnHC

aHHDBDAQNkD

JAbHHfjHfHODAA

DuHfC

QKyqtA@DA@|CnqGQ

qtB@D@|A_qGQyqtAqQyqtA

FqQyqtAC@MNTyqtAHXA

LRC

HZBLBWBwBjB

jBFB{HBjBZNxB`BU|B

LQhC

]^

FDnOnmB_mBFmBm]tFB^|m

qAsFAFU]mAmU]AU

FcC

nmQAF

CB_BgABMB

20

RBzFB]BB|BC

_mAOFBBBJB[B

ZDC

mFqAFC|BDBTA

OBjWcC

FmOPhC

]^Hfp

FO|Q~_A~H@UsE

Q|HAEQAHfpKdKQ@HAo|Q

HfWAjPiTqQG

@qHfXi]

1956-1971^G

oHfq@E~@UsEQ|H@W@EC

@@UCdsKQEHA`@FQHfAYOC

TvAXvjN~P~HMvC

GqHfjqX]

1972-1991^

b@ECG~@EKs~AXvjPPxWPAX

vbdGQTGQAMA`vhXPxWdTC

o`NoXHfKdsTQ@HC

@EK@~@EE@~AoqHfXvpdGQA

`

vd|dCAXHfTd@Q@HC

`poGQ~HfxWH@U@d|QGHA

]AHfWXgatOA@~hamxWC

TqHfLT]

1992 H^

oHfXvP`vjP@EK@~@EE@~PAOH

foW[TdTGQHAHfKdKCQTH]EQ~

^C]AqKQ@~_IavBOoi[~AL

21

W[FN~|AA[WFv|]ym^y]BWuA

1999A

300-305^C

22

T`

sBJG

BP[kzG

sksbOUsHXAs~|FsA

oIAsFsbL{Bq[P\A

FskuHA{P[kAX@gs

kCP[kFXuIG]

Danny L.JorgensenA 1999A 17-32FY}A

1996A 195-196^

DsDMHHNqYC

D

{Hib`[C

DsiAC

Ds{HWmAiisC

DsDiHyC

DsMsU{HNqC

LBiJsG

sjP}PA}

O@HiHiJpGyBFOqH

niJAouPN~iipqBpHE|C

iJs}]

overt strategy^K]

covert

strategy^A}sH}Ao[\iFK

sbNsiiHspUAiJsAo

U|zW]

Danny L.JorgensenA 1999A 66-71^C

siJsAsSMs

ItAiJsN\PC|}

Aq`OuLHswsiJAA

23

1996A

KAsOBwH

iJC

bsAHjOPOAoa\soHb

iP[CH@}lbiJsANH}iJA

iPsHAsisC

BswG

sbstA|vTLB

BP@A]AsnVbs|mC

Ray- mond Gold NP[P{tOPB

Pp[B[pPB[|]Y}A

197-201^C

.PGbaP[AsuAL[

DLOADLOsCos

zA|vTsL{[C

2. Pp[GsiHPAOnVQsH

3. [pPGvsABMPb|L{A

4. [GsO@ApPlAM

bsAsNw[Av@

HAvTA[XL{AyzX

UC

vBHG

siJs@qAw|PsH_

YAo_HAiH`JFsUhAK

sA\vT|L{A

Lke{AhLC

nfNiHPC

XspC

24

LAW[ICioAPHOsiJ

sDCMAsOiH@Uvtb

_HG

1.GXHeAsn

A

PN]

Michael Quinn PattonA 1995A 257^C

2.@GsnLXA{LeOn]

Michael Quinn

PattonA 1995A 257^C

3.@PGsLjqK`PAoH

u{PAOMWqW]

1999A 111-115^C

4.sVBBBw]B@

Danny L.JorgensenA

M@NSvA]Y}A

1996207-210^C

BsuBG

HlOeqOAU@UuOC

oUuu@OnA]bBBP

TOjqiAasOOiNy

TUA@wnuUOA~iNoCU

C@AUujPpUG

1.GBtOUoIA|oLC

2.uGAOPQeAHK

s@OC

3.qGBrBztAiHs@OAtKzA]i

HRBzoC

4.vuGORAvApAYiGA

sLBC

5.vuGp

V8AisAHBBHC

25

BRG

bP[@qAs|jqcAFN

o[HAYXNqXANU@R

~Fo\CsO{H@OR

A

u{H@ORvYOXc{H

@SxBABOolAMA{HY

hA{HO_|AHFAHKoo

{Hn]

Danny L.JorgensenA 1999A 156-160^CoR

NUUA[HOBA

L{BBPBTPWxD`

`BzjAyzC

26

|`

sHG

BbaP[Asw@[HApUG

[H

H

O

k

~

83

`

Xl

k

91

91

g

~ 5

7

~ 6

23

k

78

91

91

g

~ 9

3

~ 10

11

LBbXu@HAswXHApUG

XH

O

~

~a

pj

k

k

k

k

86

47

56

80

nmgA

nmM

g

g

nmgA

Dh

nmM

g

27

wm

nm

\s

nm

\s

[aI

nm

s

nm

D

X

T

T

k

k

53

51

L

nm

uv

@

nmgA

q

|

BbXgPLgAswQXHA

pUG

XH

O

pj

Lpj

pj

k

k

k

k

k

k

k

k

k

k

~a

nmM

nm

nm_

X

@

T

nmgA

@

nm

nmM

nmR

nm

nmM

nm

@

@

T

~

54

65

24

25

37

48

65

63

30

38

28

`

kHMDG

A@ONJm

nAbmAH{UOm

BkG

bAT

zu@AHKsbJu@eANU

AbkFJICGHD|Xkq

u@HAU{kHxNqAHOg

PLHAFLPHH[PCT

sPXAh|^Ah

HpAhoUBw

tqC

@BmG

s

DnVAiaxXXyG

]@^axGijaa

ABja

1.s

1993mxnC

2.MN }B|

MQE~Z

m{xnC

3.Bl

BBa

1.sme|

2.sFm

]G^@yG

1967 msnC

1986msxnC

2002 muFmxnC

1.a^

1984 m{nC

2.G@Hs

1979 m{nC

29

 1991 mCqOnC

1994 mCqOgnC

1997 mnC

2001 m{UnC

3.L

4.L

5.ps

6.msBF

GBXG

oXOD|X]

informal conversational interview^A

zAXi

Michael Quinn PattonA

Michael

vA]X

D|XOwDAXDVAX

HyyX~AXDXDA

XoX@NqLo@FAX

o{XLBgBBUQk]

1995A 228-229^C

D|XuIAbXi]Xt

oOCYOQDiQOAHXHA

`AgDpAWiXDY]

Quinn PattonA 1995A 229^C

D|XIAbnjqAHtTA

snPPH|CDuX

xBO_PX}nYAbbMXu

HCTD|XXRA]PHMP

D|PAsnhMDoNq

] Michael Quinn PattonA 1995A 229^C

MD|XAOAs{

unOMibAoOuxCD|

XlsBAOXXPsHYA

ohYA

X|uB@LOdAQnTAUAb

oDAo@u\uD|X~oaI

30

TBdG

MmieAij{

AOAO@tCByBBHnhP^

cAGn{FHxNqAN

IaP[C

sbaP[AbsnmgAi

P[BAe]AL{BPHA

B \HBBmA@R

MSxC

LBHPG

sHBDA]P[I_Wt

A@A@DqVAqsHPAH

[P_AoiXAX_HBCt@

OwPHiPA{|OcXAS|

uzAD[P[ADiHszPoHhA@P_

suHP_]JzBA

1996A 141-142^C

sHPAODqVAH

Kirk M Miller

diachronic reliability^P]

apparent validity^@

XvH]

HPquC

@BHG

Kirk M Miller {uHvOq{iCLXvH

] diachronic reliability^@sHkAuvHv

bPHquqPAoG]J

zBA

1996A 141-144^CbsAsQHu

vAaPA[aABU

BB

V8 vBHpB

31

MCAZT|[AOA

squ]BB

^MPA[o]OC

GBG

V8^HQnq]

Kirk M Miller {uvhOoT{AXk

uv]

apparent validity^CuvquP[{H

D`KXA]JzBA

sAsqupBB

NAoOspBv

aBaCsioA{HpBNqA

sGX[oC

1996A 141-144^Cb

V8 Aovi

32

`

}zDG

qs@J}lAL@@B@

|@Gs

zdAOH]|]sO_XGszWdALs

inAMOzdOHYOsHzW`B

TsIsHpvMKQQ]

L.JorgensenA 1999A 169-172^CzDsIkAp

O_HFoBjsHtXsBSisH

sB`sHBSOKBosHP

NpGsHumWBRPi

]Y}A

1996^CjWAsPNWz[IAOAo

zhbUBhWwsAbs

AS@M@wWdu@C

FzDbssxQ~At@]O

Danny

NHsz

DNOs{FvDA

Silverman M Gubrium by

asFvz]

The Politics of Field Research^@NasFv

jA@OasNOFvAa

sAFo

{BANq~AnscNqAt@OasRM]OF

v]Y}A

1996^CvQbH|AOLbAa

sRFFvC

zDFvDwFsiiP_A]A

sb@}liJ[ANZizasA]X

iXuAXumWWBzAs@

AvnH}A[AD[vT

A\v@lAMXC

33

T

U

@`

L{

B{Bz`G

@B{eG

]@^BG

@ab`{eAl]FRAY

LAMAjhjBCMAb

pNjPFAqWFA@HaLFQAaHN|V

{m@AHafMeNuvaN@A

HC

]G^B`G

OXkbeNnnA@WE

BUCMWC

BUOCkAWO

BBBBB~hAl

OABBBBB~hO

lAujYHlBJ@

c@CAvgBQYAw@dBvB

]p@^BsuTv@uB@Bl@B

N@]pG^CBIQBEYBQU

@CkW@A

~OTALACHNAlhO

C~OTAlHKCliH]

iHOAcOBccC

]T^A

34

B

]T^B`RlG

eAlNn@DhR@l

]pT^A\b`QUC

]|^ByXG

HaF@w~AN|vaB}AuHyXAH

C

GBNG

`_@AaNnBU@At~

UQANoBBBVAq`e@Q

ajeA_leA@iAgWmWA

XAANmAl\nAIU`eAN

lAal]nGuk`vC

TBBG

`n_AaY]BvPnB_Ai

b_BAfKKpnC

|BDT\G

pGbWQIL@ASdT\l]AbUW

`@_Al]baf|VD

AenpyL

BQ_lbpyLWAOnd|@C

|jlyjalBAAj@]Oj

alBAjlBj@WnTWAbfaDAf

GuVaDAl]NYCvCNNbepyL

AANANnNbpyL

@_NAANeFC

pyLLeAL

HYCDT\pG~H|~HYNS

ANaY

35

FC

BG

HqkaqAiD`ABa

|CaAnN`\bYWQ_@A

B`eC

B~aG

AlaA@AY{

]Olkylkb`eDAN|d|~cA

a~i|JC

CBYG

AlBk@

afAklnnjA^aFA@aC

KBG

{eAl]NJAfUA_ANfUX

ANl]Cibt@@dl]C

EB]m{E

YN_eAl]NbUf@{EAn_b

{fEWA``U@fC

QBiG

l]ny@bMAiH]iNAy`A

OkjlAOkjkAW

nAWEBUCWCBUC

`AABlBAlAclCIAn

~WclA]bWcl`FN|

}C

Q@BAG

36

AlBk^

w

As@AaHYWAABHeA

aeaBaC

LBcJ

@B\G

TOOQA[bilWAWQWBQ

EYAkbs]ik^Akb]i^hAN

mjUC

GB`

G

akl]AyMAYT

a]p|^AOAOIA

q]pGLqBjqgaq^hAFaIAl]IB

NBIVLjmWB``~BBB

~ALjd`C^{^hCpGl]

HhApGOlNbOWj@NlApGO]lNbO

Wj@AKW@pN]lC

TBRG

akl]Ay

aAABnRAR

NabC

|BNDG

l]y@qR^AHxXUA`~b

NAOkjlAkjAOkAjk

AkjC

BG

nA`UbIlWA@|

MAYT

37

W~

PJpL]p^A`}bWA@|

lAWQsMB@sBOB]@KQH

BKQHU^BQ_lBJCl]NRJl

NuA|WJuClBkB]ljpk

kWhCsA_sM`TnsAAA

]s@CNNuJ_l_ABNu

C|lW]FAN@`FFAFWA\W@

jJM@JGAJFAI@j]nuAo

qi_^bJWA\C

BfG

Al]Nnn@JA

Kb`fWAjA

N`TOWC

CBQG

l]AkzYvaWBkAT

OQQWCF|sJnJAN|

nujAjbTOWAA\WQAN`qY}\C

KBuEG

bQWAal]nHubAKqW

LAonpC

EBJG

]@^BJG

@JOb`_A|ApG]H

`e

AiA|JAdU

iHbWJA{NHjhDhA@}|JCJ

uBvC

]G^BJz`eG

38

MwAb

JANjbfWJn_Ajb`|u

nPjBpGkAJNYWn_C

]T^BJL{G

JAnNaoaA\AnA

aOnAbHvaAnI@A

qthOQXA@HhWjp

JHv@L|NQoAHIVnb

HvMJVC

JjlYAjlbH@GlAp

GSlN]AL|NLl]]]Ak

^BUAUnQjqAWnQA

bA`kU@Al]xAN

bW\AOYi_AAN`e~

MAmA`bC

]|^BJ

lG

@HHA^bUAkbsBkbAYV~A

aC

QBvG

\WAvUslAbN|

_AblWWAUiNKvwWC

Q@BG

bUACCnva@A@Xl

C{NuJ~ANFCOMfoX_N

HGbWAkbsAkbmANbUC

QGBG

mUANBYBMWA@

@C

39

t@pGJpAWmoFi`pv

TwbCFbWKB~A]bU]

^A\W`eclwclbWC

QTB]FG

b`JANP_Ae@AW\

lBe~Ab`T\C

\BkF^PAUNC

bFWCEgl]pA{Uk

`AHugkl]Wr

Abl]p~OapAapO

TQArgAkBpAOTQ

ArgAOTQkBpAr

]MkBp@gAiApP`YCO

C

F\TJGBMBsMBPBlAlIbX

leiHC

B^`

@BFeG

b^oqAlB@BkCn@b

`yB}A]nC@JAW@Ve

@_lA`A@sMAkA@XlC

bA@Bkkl]|uqvAHFdC

GB^G

b^A|q`|\W|l}bi

lWAwCo|}Asy]}@^]x

^z

40

^

FXle@WAv|aNbU}_

AbWAoal]nbeAk@YA

@TUATnAnXlFA@WpA

vn

}Aani]^vYAYivQN

QC

TBk]W^G

k\wAU^ubXle@~|

@AqU|BI}l@AgLBBBB

NBaBlFBBLBvBBeQGA@

WDh|aaaNkFe`WAok

~C

|BCG

uCvPuvbOCHa|NbaLC

AC@CCAYOCC|QEL~XlAM

A{bubJ

@wC

bC]kkOPtAkCC@CAkC

@CAH@BTBBC|_CjCAlTCOpCCYC

kCAkXDADhWwgAGCOCAX

CCTCOkCAkXCA|COCABXDhw

gACOkXA@hbCXlACOkCAkh

wgACCSCOkXApGbCSXlAoNnXl]

msBFA

2001A 244-245^C

vBXl`

@B_FG

G

e@Aa|bgLa@iKAF~

41

KA|baWWBKBlTFC

_FAkBkB@|bAnjB{X

Av|iDkAkGu{bAnXFA@

WnwvA|KvN|wAmbU

i]nH|AbUAknlA

LBkBF^PBlBl|C

GBG

QXaAb\a~TUA\

@KB@B@MAM@B@qalM

@AW@B@lB@MBQ_lA

CW]@MAMJ\oANoIUAa

C

TBoG

i@qAu@HN}lNBkBsBsB

lBlhWlAaNWsiAvw

@AeYQrnT_AXlNXoC

beOWxA@

OnAq`bN

}AdUjaLnAnPae@{A

oHe`eaiH}AbbN}FA]ue

b~aOC

|BXlG

Xl@jPWAojWOie\L

PCq`AeO}HAISYASYecArA

xVrAe}AOXAXOeT

AXWgamArCAOA@j

OAWY

gYB`~B@rBXNPrArn

42

gCAOmXAmXOXkeAOa

lWA@UeUTmCAOrD]A

HANOiHOXlCAOpANea

pAeaNCAOBkBlBlBFB

sBsB_@AAOFPAFPOYA

bA@KQBWeQCBUeQGArAB

BB|rWwgCA

A~BjAW\

QALb]mCAal]Akl]@aC

eC

bXluAaq`beNwgwFA^]nh

u^A\e`auPqa^auOPC

BiG

Be`aN}FAdUOl]BlkB@v

HMkvvC

ikvXewgAvM@UAM

@A}iAkl]|bNAJR@Av

NNJAal]CH@gRAvN

WFCpGAvNxMwQK

bWAANWCQJZgANjA

CAQJAl]nnbeAAb

N`eFAniC

JRAv|@LlALlFAvWY]A

bLAa^hQNQAKBNqC

BG

@Be`aANNWy

alAW

alyAknK@lbYWAHOw]p^C

43

rnnaVAl]waC

@akl]MXkl]NAAMA

tAyalA@lbYWCXkB]

kkl]Ja@B@FW~AnAW

AyWalAYWCBCpGbAh

lA`ljC

CB^G

JRAkN`Aal]e

{^aA@W

KBLG

iA@pOkvHD^aAkv|@

JMAClAfGyAClgMxbnJal]

WHhCGpOSkvAD|@lAl

N\bafAl]^qlWLAHhC

EBwFG

LAkN`bWAW\Xke@]

LzAb|PTGBAQ_lb~

AUbWAbzWn

QDBBOBQsMB@sBQ_lB

pjpGBoBoBQBBlBlBLlBl]

AANbWvPANe\b

vPWAXlNi@qC

B`G

XlLAknal]`XhA@n

sXLMzXa|PAt@a~`PA

s_sCok]|aeLBAFAa

WBMBlBAk

44

ahNAoINOjNqA]oO@iHN`

e~|ApGboNANANF`FC@

abN`eA|d@MAlA@d

NCb|DA@DOCAan\QJ

NLAAICAN@_NACt@

DO`AanQJNLAQJn@Al

]I`ANbXWlA~OAC

~b`M

``NiHFC

45

G`

`nyzA[\FHIDn

Ao]AlCB\wAXla

BABMC

B@C

`JACCAaN|vbW@A{

PCA@DyzAayCzAC@

2001^C

]msBFA

@B@CG

@C``~BXl

aA|PCCbUWAHWLQHW`~OW

AoaiH\CCC~XlA`~QAjLTC

CNnXlApGON~AiJAq`bGCT

CNnXlApGO@XNAq`bNIFACC

GBUCG

YCWCAajpbuF_ADkXDApGS

hiH@PAkWXASkCCGCADXA

SsCCTCADktdApGlFYCAo

AoDUubvAO``FbC|CADXAU

CCCAhw}QA\hBnQAp~CCCA

DkXOXDAUkCCCCSCADkD]m

sBFA

2001^C

TBCSG

kC@CAkCC@CA]OtCO

46

Magpn

Lk@P

tOC

@XllvMwAwlN|bXlAMb

AXll|]Ll]CapGLlL]AXllN|

vhwlApG

al]AXl|bvw

leG|@XlAOiHeWL|XlCpGlL]

AXllNue@CpGl]HelQXlA

nXlAsXle@\wk]nAnCCLAAn

lXlC

|B@CG

b@C@HHoyCz|a`^al]

Coan\A@O`A@OCACW\

QsMB@sBGQ_lBBOBCDC

WJBQGDN

LA@JnOFt@JO

z@iBBOBQsMB@sBQ_lC@Cq

`ObU@I@Ib|C

B@CTG

i|IG

]@^BC@Ce@WAal]bYWyWalnh

~AG@CA_Ao@NO`

GC

]G^B@@CA@wn@AC@CnziAb

A`^LC|aiWYC

]T^BpG@CD{AK`A@CNn_ALFH~i

@

CAb@CoqAanNB_A@S@Co^C

]|^B@CApGlnIAl

Cn@@C

17 B

27 Ao@

47

LBXle@kG

@BkG

HUA`q{woqAubXle@

AkvaXlkwALCAa|kva

`WwgkC

@XlkjbXle@U|I}lA@]Q@I

k~jPA@nN`kAM

_

AkvvaBl]aNAk~i@qC

GBkeu@G

kv|a@B@B]KQHW

^BOB@JB@B@AbJW\Am

etANnuA@Aib

WbJA\WAGC

TBkL{G

bk`@nQGG

@GB

kA`mWB@HhB~XB

q}lkB

GG

UW`FeC

TG

^aAwgAU`bWnA

vo^C

|G

`a@CAe@@C

GN

C

48

aNP_Ai_cAbcWg`mWAgkvw

gA}lN_Al]aWAlaAHtmA

`QCAai|HNAUuHcvC

Ga

al]|AaW\QKJAC@JN@a

AOknJFOknAkvfGAa

al]}JATN}@JAN`qLF@aA

@QKJANNwgqLFQKhaCpGOkA

n[gAiH`c^C

CGlF

@zeLWAl]]@S|

`PLAt@bU]@FMyA

~bfNo^AAnC

KG

EGL

@U`HnnAt@n

P@C

L|JDJAkvgU`

twqLC

QGv

SuOvAe]fhA@v

efhC@vOChAC@hCOA`@

OCpG`kAl]nOwVOAA

fCpGOkCAfCC@eo^t

@Fn_U@hC

Q@G

DnOW

C

49

49

QGGe

DnO`WCbMGAkvaal]Be@

NaANkNAplBfBbB

FPA^{kv|oal]WAkl]nb~Ak

l]h^abl_ANNC

Ba

@Ba|G

a|qbrDW|ABjhOFtXXlw

C

GBPHG

1. akl]C

DFDC

TBa{G

2.akl]tC

3.pGOA

4.atC

BC

1.}lC

2.kB]NC

3.C

4.kB]

aaC

5.mBqFeC

6.msBsqFeC

7.m]^B

qFeC

8.m]^BqFeC

9.m]^BqFeC

mBqFeC

11.mGBGqFeC

12.mI]}^BIqFeC

13.mB

qFeC

14.kB]AVFAnBAnBT

15.C

16.C

17.tC

18.B

C

nB_C

Aa

|Ba~G

iPG

b~G

1.@C

2.@C

3.@C

4.@JC

5.G@

JC 6.n]}@JC

7.C

8B 9B 10 TJAS

WwC

50

b~G

1.BBU@C

2.VC

3.z@C

UAUBBBQBlAT\C

5.s@C

6.sMQC

7._QC

8.@C

9.C

10 l

@C

11.OC

12.p@C

13.C

14.s|

C

15.al]H

wAaOsA

kUW@VpAkO@B@A

]O@B@A]O@B@C

l]HwAOAO

AYjpWPAl@O

Ft@OA]@OFt@OA

]@OFt@O]p|^C

vB

@B|G

@||gbrDAbaN|C

GB[HG

1.FHC

2.al]u@W

PC

3.@FvWHC

4.`

HC

TB{G

qW[HNAT`AAaC

@[AankkkhCkkk

hOHOAYOOknabkeA

ANnabeC

B

@B|G

51

AaNNa~BBFh|A

nON|A@AN}lFC

GBPHG

al]BtBtB

TB{G

eHC

1.}lC

2.tNC

3.DkNC

4.mBqFeC

msBsqFeC

6.m]^BqFeC

7.m]^BqFeC

8.m]^BqFeC

9.mBqFeC

10.mGBGqFeC

11.m

I]}^BIqFeC

12.mBqFeC

13 VFC

14.B

15.tBtnC

16.C

17.C

18.B

C

XlC

|B~G

`CpG

Q

OaABb@BAP

PYHAbUC

@A|]`iXG

@Oakl]Xkl]A@P]@`A~jP

QGJQJA@J@wn@C

GO`aAUWn@A]@AQGJQ

JA@J@wn@C

TOXkl]tAUWC@Xl]MV@P@A

~QGJQJA@J@wn@C

|OP`PtAC@]@A~QGJ

JA@J@wn@C

B

beAal]izvBiGlBiXub|BL~p

52

iHKApGnKpnK@aOAOXkb

CLAk|ApXkBkBB~cBkB

kBaA`IBNABp@UPC@

LaN_`FC

mB

@B]G

H@]ijPHU|IG

]@^

B]@u{DApGIuaIngLaAl]N

nC

]G^

BaH vaAoewanAYv

TNl]BAoNnC

]T^

Nl]]u@tGw~xWA|^A@|N

e_AaxW^C

]|^BNl]QNXANnC

GBG

@AnbwT~~Cq`bA

|DnlqlNA@WWKIQ@IQ

GIoqAbQGILCpGObnlA@W

iHACpGb@lANnN

TBBmG

nu@NOvwATwA

l]beTnaOTUAGuXXXnha

FAA@UvCWAl]BvB}uHnaA

bQVAagaAgaGuYYH{bnhaFvA

gaAAq~KDQGDApG

~iHC

53

|A

KD]QGD^Hi~]OKD]QGD^A`A

GunhaFAAvANApGeOb

`n@_NFpGONe\blAnLBw

A@_NAObXlAsw

aIAoqbl_CPNAl]

OTUGu{bn}lhaFvA}v}X}A

vqYBHBBBvB}_AANY\bVW

HAYYa@OAuNYj_

Ab|Ab|O}BvBBHBBYA

pGOb

]LBw^OYBHBBBvB}C

pGNem|NnwmAoAl]|B

`hAAngaATMsBTJGB_

QBs@BBOATWAgaGuYYHA

{~XAnhFAAnULvANnNbgalA

AA~a@AW\_lQB]

O~HnFQHW^BQMsBs@Ai

z`GuYYYAoOAslvA

NAN|JdlC

pGONemlnwbOBAbl_A

FwBAl]lBANbXWl

sXWAAga`AANNJsXA

v_C

54

T`

P

q{BJBlwL{jPA

boqAaaEF\haBFHMu@

HAja@_`H~@{eAas

C@

APdBYitBtB

BmFBu@HBLHXjG

@BtG

SlBkAOtA]AlB@B]@B

]B]tAM]]tXkB]kkl]XH

kl]AOXl]tblBkC

GBtG

aA]A`SnfBSnfAL

tMNl]AohYiHCMLO_[`

AoPaYM`K

a@|orDiC

TBG

NOBsaYAkQaMXkCa

C]AkSnftMNl]BkBB]kBBkBM`

SnfC@k[H|HhA

HP`YwC

|BmFG

|O@|AOtYPmvE

MA~OCA@HADW

a|orDC@HaAXlN|

{wApGYKA

H`e

55

C

BUPDG

WoHsbOoHQi\ALOkn

AOM~HAOCoH]ADB

aqBB\wkkvBuH@a@HC

BaPBG

oPH]A`ePnBPBWqAH

kBkBlB@BBPBHBqWqHCoP`

HW`SYAo@hPHOHu

|X{

C

56

|`

WxPT

@{OBOnA|Nl]LHaM

AFooyvTAU|

WdYWxBTAPHu@WwTK

`CPAbU]|@TWwAal]

PHuC

BWdG

AG@sAquWEUCv

uWCUvkAq`AlsA}W

cAas~C

AGA{XPtYAPtYV

AV]pCBK^CApUG

A

l

BYaByBC

@

BYYByaBcC

k

]l

~]

]@

]k

XkBYYByaBcFX

kBYYByaC

RBYaaByBC]

APlPAn@C

ByaC

PXkAPYWn@B@P@PAY

Wn@C

XYYBByaFXY

YByaBC

57

~]k

XYYBByaFXY

]

]

YByaBC

BYaaByBC]

AP]lPAAn@C

BYaaByBC]

AP]PAAn@C

kB

YUBTByaC

YUB

TByaC

YUBTByaC

BYUByaC

ByaC

ByaC

ByaC

kyaBYYFkyaC

wG{UWAWEQHW~H`uw

kB

S

nf

`H

@

vCwajAHkABrDgB

ajpyaBaAOwRpBnQB

A@oALa~C

GaqD`KA@HaORObaA

fMANnuvaN@Auva

eAanbjWAoO_eAbNha

fA@|LAL\B@}L_

lQBJBYSX]_uANLb|

lW\ba~AA@il@_lAi]

zAqWAeC^Auv

58

AHOwCpGiSY

Aa@JQiAe

kF~YAHDwC@nAbWgyBBdB

z|rAb_QBBiAj_A

baKBCANbjfWUC

IGUWAIb|A@|WLQGA]H

{qau_NQC

LBTG

rAjHLrJCpYH

FA@|YHFYHFhFLF@A

|rC

Hb {n`U@fuEApGJpUBAlkn

AW@ApNn_B`yCC

pGOfAb_@AaHnN`eL

axnC

UWAqiJoqAanNl]Q

AiN\wWAo|}@C

bAakwgqBFAobkBn@A

`WnQW@BAQW@B\WQAbkB

`A}QBA

}B}ANi`@AN

wgLFCbkBn}aAnEb`W

^aC

pGXkwn^a`AanaAXl]

naANOboqnalC

b_FJRAUW{oAH

vB~~BnnjAHKQRAO`ahb

dC

59

bAaOs@~`~AHaIbhCoq

kB]kaM@B]@aPaK

aCL~BLANeaAqn@@QAanH

_lB|uKM^AP~ANUbeFC

L

60

`

~BL

Bb~G

HbJAaH|N@JuM@MAsHx`A

LOuuC

Jl]CT@JA@Ve^`

AW|^TJGsC

C~CCJM^`JBsBQGDNL

aA@

JnAt@JnOiC

bBaA~@B@B@B@JB

G@JBn]}@JBAlTJASWwC

~Qae@YB@B|@YBsQG

QDLAL]|eQGQDsA@DnO

@C

LBG

^AXkCHne@]LzM~sC

o]A`n_AanNBMlAe

sBsmXAavlBlB

sBBNBNBBlBBLrCXl

XBBFPBFknBbC

BL~G

]taBBU@BVBz@B

aBs@BsMQB_QB@BBl@BOB

p@BBs|BaBC

QepBBsQ@AQMWge{

BkB_BsB

61

brBsBTC

uivAOzhiAwAb@

pAbNANn~xW}gbWCuiv

bHUHONAAHbUW|P

YAYiULhaBC

62

`

D``Bz

P@WU@AaD``A|HSP`

UkCHUNN~M~

G

B~pBzG

@BlG

pGO~p`A@a|bNLBzANOR

NpJe

sWhASA]DhWC

pGOHaA|b\TC~XlAoN|DhW

A@OAKoaHC

GBkG

bX[NFAoaN@scAc

QANrbcAbLW\WL

eLAAAL\WACunONiHFA

QHWHSYASYepcA

NsWIFC

pGOQKplANnLWLeAAk

lnozYv

AklnbeLznzvAO

izvANnhsWIFC

q`a|bjACAqt

TBG

WC

LBL`BzG

UW]LGpGBDH`BBAW

63

O\iJADWAaH|b~Wfw

AUDN~L{O@C

64

|

R

@`

cR

H

Arnold Van Gennep]Z

A 1996A 21^NHs||

HRfBHPsYHmBtBU

AzLLR~AqHhAzXY

PANkP@dAXoFTOPA

]@@PAYOWuqLzv]

Passage^C

Gennep zAj@ucvA{b

tmAYAMAb

t

mA]XPtAOAmubw

vOP]AqA

1994A 14^C

Gennep XALTVA@Ou

The Rites Of

v]

rites of separation^ApdvBbCuLv]

rites

of transitiom^AjHu@TMWdA@|Wdbi

CTOuXv]

@CoTVPAbP

tApbOjIALb|~

XaAXbBWn]

26-27^C

rites of incorporation^ANOPs|Y

O\

B MorrisA 1996FZA

1996A

E]

1985^b@g

A.van Gennep Rzs

@A

|UA

Gennep qLzXYz[IAHXH@

Gennep qLzKobc

65

C

c

Dp

E

Gennep RBLBX

XAE{e@XAL

gennep {O@WsbAORYo

@qOLALk[HCE{R]g

XX

229-239^C

E{AbRaPLVAu|

HwAXGH||a]E

… …..X]EA

1985A

A

1985A 239-246^C

EXA

Gennep j

Oq@wMaAt@

wMaAOWiAqwwaFwMa

ApvBBCqwMaHwMaApX

]EA

1985A 246-248^C

HUNH

Gennep qLzAHEqLz

X[IAbccNqRG

HL{AqfHfMABl]HbAfH

NBAHNl]Aot

XHxAf

HdAaNfHhmUALBuLv

AA@fHANA`AaA

aP`uvC

Al]NfkFAHXlk

eAaMYosuXvCAA

zeBvBWsAl]ARAhqi`

TAOwuLvqCNDiAl]H

HxksBAHOuuASbT{`Pl

66

]uv

vqC

AA`mAJ|ASuL

JON`JAvB@sAF[

jBl]MuvN~ASBuLvAAaB

MAOMHPDHA@u

XvA_FhOPuLvqCoA`

LvBApPe@AMtuvNC

FaAl]XONJXUAPuvA

AjlA`

o{^aAoO@

quLvL{A^aeAn|L~iiJA]uLv

qAAl]EbjUAapAAN

\mWA`FPFuXvC

Ajlval]A~esX

dX|PO_t}lpAuLvqAdANb`

Xe\W~PgaAINeA^al]

EYhSuXvAii@qFC

L{

{]XB^

i]^

cpUG

]^

N]^

hE]L^

A]L^

Y~a]X^

Y]

X^ `]L^

R]L^

ND]L^

]^

E]L^

J]^

v]^

]L^

Fek]X^

a]X^

]X^

_F]L^

]X^

]L^

o]^

i]^

^]L^

L

wF]X^

s]L^

sX]X^

NcNqAL{{XTNq[G

@BYXHbafWA

67

BLBXGsTB@ANaA

ot@saAvaiAn

YSwUAHQYiHso

C

GBqPMYAiHo{PYA

WPCUIBBpAO`P

Aoq`pHPKAFjB

AS[J@u@HHP`YA

hXjFAAPdSXnBPBP

CiA`pjPs]La

uA 1987A 101-102^C

TBuF`a]pbWA``HBXB

D

N^As`lBl@B]AbAa

]j]p`la]tvBbWo

vPaMwv^]A

1989A 218^C

68

G`

\R

Ha]R[IPtjwqAN

@UlYFA\A

YOjsbPAAN@HD

PQqC

`AH]

Bronislaw Kasper MalinowskiA 1884-1942^P

J]

A.R.Radcliffe-BrownA 1881-1955^\R[IA@

`R\C{H|bG@O

QAHTuUDOhhNpL{AYOqTu

1981^Ai

UoQqCGOVADH{]QA

XAH[I|zF{AHAA

nqL|c\ADqLAS{|WU

LUP\

|E|AiXAH|@sb

zC

MJPH\Xtj[IAi

OPs~AHi\sC

\RAq\B

`a\H|\TRG

B`\G

@B`Bz

qz[IA`|PsN@A}lG

Ac

`AA\NBzA

HKVgDC

AO@NO

69

@{PA@UUi

PApgBBBVP]UA

q`l]VaABzAOaGuA

HvD{]ZA

GB@

OaA|Aq

O@Nl]A]]NAa

1984A 119-120^C

1996A 87-88^C

@A

{X~HaPRiY]^A

1990A

40-41^C

LB`a\G

@Bs\

HjaxA]sbAyax

j`sABHLUPPCY

AAUsXhAiH@R[A

boiHvzMUaLsAiO

C

a`{

BhEBiBABBJBUAU

PAHKa``_w

CYBT\BoBBC_AaaHA

FsqPABaj

|AAinnoHAFMC

GB|Nl]\

FW@Bz`~AnaAtF

DHPP[LRC

aaBzLi{Bn]p_nBwgn^A

gHPxPAR@HAo

HRNqA

70

BJRPPLC

p{l]b`eA{o

BXkAib[dApG`kAodhb

AVUNqCD{bY

vApG{l]AN|bjxsUdl]C

TBavQ

a`GAowvQqYTwAy

a\A]Aan`M~HAa

~B@ANF

AagDBA`ATw~HA@s

TaHYAt@`bavQPqYC

|BHYsT{PdT

L{AXGbVHiMjaHYAo

Yj{`{WBBkkB~YOC

@BABisHYP

vlG

GYOVoeHiT[A

AQ{@AqPd

OY@sT{BMdTL{C

AGYOl]W~AAAiIBIBj\Bp\B

AIOBrAIHBrAj\

IPIB|Ap\Sj\B]j\

ASp\A]BBBCOAiHX

PANP`YM{PC

GL{ABkkOBth

oDC

A

iA@bzL}jHYsT{PdTC

71

B

@BBaB|E

|\G

zL|A]``N_YHcA

PAYO@|{C

FtBtBBmFsE|A

LLaAPWAbB

zBanUC

{bupJL~L`A]UTtGAao

~AHaIbhAoPaKNn@

~eFaAp`Ae@@Q

~|Aoa]|^Q_lB@|uKM@C

GBbaBY\

MOi@AoqQL{oA

HjpwBp{tOAae

jAX@hMmC

cBhA@aOLk@]AnH

ApXlANOUaCb

ubvAbOAaXliAN

baAULHanAC

]AXlAaN|bMPHAo@y

@PPHAt@B``GdU]pG

~tBlO^Me]W

rYC

TBWjpaO

b|sATMH

h]A]ta|V@Hi{aHBhB]O

lAL~Ae@@Q

72

pNAMA]]oQC

bAaO

@YyjHXu|Ah

HPAkF~tAYaaPvC

b`ABB~OlDAonDjBe

EjAolDAAAAOaaOqBdT

|a|C

73

T`

q[R

e`RAY\BcAq{

H[sARcH`BaB|\CA

`h[{HQVNqh

N[sARGBtz[BFHPRB@

[|hC

BG

H`FsBR}BAPsP

AYOG{C

Gh{A@NGCGP@AP@

Jt]AbP@UA]P

@CTDFAAJRASAJqA

SAJWMOqASUHOq]iA

AoT

GOAIM}AOAbH

jhHTG{DC

GA{bHM[C

AGWAH{XAA@Od`RA

t@S{XPF@M`R}At@

AoPAX{bHYAbBl

HAN|X{bH]iA

[GYOHFAncC@H`Be

BpBaIHSXP@_nchCj

A~AeHLhnAoHLqHAH

FAOqhAAO@CD

74

AOq

1993A 66^C@

1993A 85-89^C

1993A 74-76^C``FA

``FAhOqA@@FBBtA

O\iJGgAPF~b@_ACsLeAA@HA

GhPXv|I]iA

AOqAbH[oF|^Au@a

HAL

iHl]AP]iHl]AR{XHF[G

C

bL{Aal]Ptj

A@baq`AJBlB_FBwoq

HA_{XhHsFt@bAa

BYBM~d`Nl]AO@

FCoHRPHBNAA

NOG{C

LBtz[

gBBBBBZBPHUNA

dh~vAw@WLjHBCM

nd~wAtz[@AHH

BAWV@UYC

bHAtzOcAOqB

BMAUA@OqAjaA@Oq

BBMAUAh|BsbHA

P]A

qlD~M_IA

1999A 36-41^CHAHBBjMBA

PsHYFMAD

PMYMA{uHX@vHuPMvCHX

@PPMmnPmen]A

mnG

jHAPaXwAPXAP|XAPNC

75

1992A 69-71^G

HA^CBHApGHGApGC

menG

soAAo`AMC]AU]FM

]AUFD]CajAU|jC

bMPHtzPF

XAHtz[YOuThM[vAHaxpG

nFzQdAANnOThtMPA

oTtOG

@Bt

ndANn~AnbDn

On`NuNvuvHuvuvMA{bBM~

zWCb~bWWABN{bmW@WC

GBHYt

bHnHYAwaPYAP]n

PWMMYA

TBMYt

bHW{PMYMAnzLt]pG

KrPtzM^Bt]pGsAPtz

M^MWMFt]pGb~PwWADPWM

FoM^AHFuHX@v]A

biHo{A]``tGAa|PvB

BFdTisPA]``

yHYW_Caq`

]|vwH_X{`FPAo

|XMA]``D}aABuD`vAA

|AsqPHYtBMYtMYA_u`v

@

1992A 69-90^C

t~]PFHMMYC

vwAXlBU

76

AUC

BRPFH

baBDPBRqFBBa

Ae{XRPFHVC

ROS@Abs}HNALwI

DAb|PxU\hKqA

FAwRHCAH{UBH

wMHefAHiFCAPWiqA

]bH[BHNl]OAoRB

|jDAP~UAPHHA{Ha

eWF@A]baAlB

H]}A

1996A 1-11^CaQHD

{AdTFRDwAHaxMvs

cAPRAci}CRPa

XA@haAGhTOHHibaA

Nl]]^A

1990A 43-44^C

L{BBsbTAGHiOVWdAHK``

~ALHH

|

Sl]C]q`_AaNTApG

pUBAlknBAW@AB`yAH

~C_FA`jFAHA@n

DP`vB~Bnnj

AnDBHCD^aen|LAkv

AfGyAgMxbl]Wh`AaNA

l]LHhAXlA~TAoTWd

{XHFHC

vB@[

CaUAh]P_F

77

UFXHt@RHANO

HP{@t~@@sbCFonDAHU

vL``M`hBXAHXt@@

cQPyzA@UC

@[Hjz[AbvoiXFaT

IBDTCz[HBaQkAiOXFU

NUQBHAv@U@[AsxyC

N|pIAOjz[BaTIBDT

Cz[BqUBaQkG

@Bjz[

jNz[iA@OzYAGOz]A

58-80^CHz[IHAyC

]@^

zY

lbmgnXuvRDAL{

AA~BwbmanlDDVnXBRB

Ti[IAF~aHAXA`

IA{XjNF[zYIC

]G^z

bmOESnukAzkavHHh

BCoz[]tjNF[XnG

1.H]^P]z^nC

2.ziHCHAO@AH@`AN

AC

3.HPzKCHAzO

zJaAiJPC

ozBAH@]Pa^[IAjN

1996A

HF~

@aAOWA

78

z[[Fi@BAF[HFiHAHA

`bAYBFAO@[M[Qk]

A 1996A 58-68^C

zYOzsAiAH`[

]A

1996A 68-71^C

GBaTI

lGuAjAHAjC]yBig^vAo@

q@HZM`

DA@ANiAnH

xNqAH`CHajeA@

f~wB\B]BGQ|~^ADw~s

H@ALHAN@AFRCy

Aa@Ani`A@K@A

i{XnWiH[A@`A]LAGiYGusA^F

SA^]C]XDg^v

iAaR[A@jRAt@

jOs|

XPs]ZA

1996A 52^Co{@[Pj

F[XAFaSF[A{Hh@AWA

zkaAHkAk^CCvbaAN]

A

2001A 50-60^C

TBDTCz[

DTCz[jNz[AuL[HA

]ObMHzkDC

D@PPAPPAOWFPWt

uAuPAjhH_AngNkAPi

\wO~P

RfPba]A

|CYOxyBBec@

1994A 212-214^C

79

D{HsTCzAmDCDnGuHWTA@

WLAMM]C@WnFA]C@WA]C

… … …

HCzA@WqBGWBTWB|WeBWDrBWB

CWBB]Cv]DnyZA

zNXAzbO}BLAFAUDk

OzAG@CC

|I_C

|BqUBa[

qURHHwuQFfPAe

cAQKaDdCD~AAQPML@ApG

`QKaWDA@kNOaaWCHA

HFma@gnBmjsQgnAF

QKaWD]bA

QFQKaG

@Gseh@L`uC

1989A 375-377^AH@h@

zhNkWiJPA

1992A 88-93^

GGx

aBMaBQKaC

TGx]aB^xaC

|GxxWaBCsaBHBaC

GFoaC

Gx|aBaBaC

CGsxaBPaBPaC

KGxsaBiaC

EGxMaC

QGcHbBjUaFHebgC

WzA[XFjF[HBBDTaQ

MHAo[{b`Cpa

kvgW`

80

OHqUHFDhwgGeHXBw`

FAXDHHFMWdOaUC

81

|`

R

jAbWBHbB`FAGOH

@UAu|tNqHxCA`F

~O`[qAHxkFFPYP

PCobuvPtOAiHb~

WMXAHUNw~@HxNqRC

B

W~]UHApGNv@RHxqAgT

LjAA[WUtbNqjPA]AHB

oT@N~HxNqC

@B

]@^G

1.uG

oiG

] 1^JG

@B@@oAOHC

] 2^^G

GBGGoA@@AhxqC

iG

] 1^w}G

hC

] 2^n}

G

LhF]}A

2.G

1996A 34-35^C

82

SWLCH^rA~NACjpu_A

UNAhqBP]}A

3.G

XvfNAUNPthC~VVy

WC

]G^kG

@ITKAIGKA@KCIUYAbF

M]kA]bk~^AbfeAqWU

TUYiAWUAWiWLAUi

Al]}A

]T^HxNqG

bXAOiuAHWH

xPWMFiqAoPPF@COAH

]POFAIqtApO

@K@KAOLAhw}Ahn}A

bqWA@q`ITKAKA@KA

otOHxBBPYPC{

OBWMB@UAoLWFA{X

qAF{uvOiLqASOiAg`HF{

uvOvHAN@KBP@YF{uvOi

ASXYoo]A]A

GB~

]@^G

bXuT@C

1.TG

] 1^eGq`BBC

1996A 35-37^C

C{A_hLA

1996A 37-38^C

uv

125-127^C

83

] 2^\kGbHmuvFA\

kA\Ao

uvC

] 3^~GaBPWA`C

]G^kG

1.G

~@HaDABnBAO@bLl

AbWDAXQDQGD~C

2.`FG

~HSDA[HLA@QGDQDYiC

]T^HxNqG

bAOBBBByOH@

Aio{HQ~uvBuvuvBuvtFX

POFq{tOCuv{XFRqP

AAuv{XFRqPAyFuv

PFYAuvPFY]A

128-129^C

TB

]@^

G

BDnW`CBMTG

1.GKA@hAiEhCb

B

TC

] 1^G|oE|oALSTAjBpj

BpC

] 2^GSW|BgaCjBp

o|Ap]o|AHKjK|Ap||

C

Aj

84

1981A

] 3^G|oE|oAjBpC

2.GKAWjpC

] 1^jG|oC|oAxW_SjpFxWn

jBBpTAPxW_PC

] 2^pGToo|AxW_jpFxWnj

zBzBpzTAPxW_PC

3.GSWBfCOjsAfOeCGOH

fAC

] 1^Goo@AM]g^@

AWDC

] 2^wGA@oKojAWIuKQA|ATQ

i@AU@UAhHQU@C

] 3^GA@@ooEAASQ

GBGQ|BTQOC

] 4^GoAWLrGCh_

C

] 5^T_GLABAuvrALu

vB^AUu

]G^~G

1.G

] 1^GsZgC

] 2^GwZgC

] 3^GRNsC

2.G

] 1^jGBBLIA]iJi

TwC

vurv]}A

1996A 19-34^C

85

] 2^pGbBC

3.G

] 1^GDnHoNA]bXWAS

C

] 2^wGTwAHIN`MVwxA

q`e

vMwCKUATQUAQ@UA

QUAsQGUADEUATQ|UAQUAU

CUACUAUAQGUC

] 3^GAaAANC

] 4^Gh_IA`bC

] 5^T_GJmHTwAHIN`b

]yLA

1983A 32-39^C

]T^HxNqG

WiAbuvFuvFA

]@PASujv

AupvpA

YOAHFXHFaCBYtCpG

FAhAXHRLqF

FA@h@~ABPAYXP

aCCSpGbF@]jptOA{XQ

PYBP]A

LB

OiaIAi@BANOb

|]pT^~|]

Mo|uOaItAtNqon_t

OA]AaInNqC

1981A 129-130^C

pDBN^tOC

86

tO]{bFYBaCPApbD

Ahb~|AHAouvOWMaBt

AeH@UA_hNOuvqAHH

b~A{XuvqNA`Ahbi

ApiBT\BEBA{Xb@H`@

{`PaYC

By

qHW~]BB~^PRoA

YO@HxAI]TBB@^qh

B]GBGjFp^PB

]P@BP^tOH]B^tAH

FXWMPFBBBAPPAy

AHPNqAbMAON

~P@bNqHxAFXH

bYC

A

FB

87

TdRXAoi{B

DnB@TPWxBUUBMPU

HTCb|Ai@BHxNqRAiH

o{tGBtz[B@[BFHPRH

UHxq[CzLcRAoUc

AHFOBLOXC@\

RAo{`

\Fad\

B|dTmHi{aO\CqTB|

zAU~bPbHxq[B\ch

wo{FCTB|zRA

e{XSIHSC

@`

SI

`POyHAYXW

SIC

@BAaG

AHaSAOxyHSCas

AkUW@VpAkO@B@F]@

B@F]hO@B@C

GBDT\kDG

DT\bal]DDhAPxyHA

HDh@DAal]uOtXC

88

HOeAC

TBWG

WAbxyHX{LC

|BVu@`G

a`HhHu@HA]UqBUu@

PA`HtjC

BRG

aAxy

BJG

bJH|AOxyHHN@JhC

CBCCCOG

bC]OAHC@CAl|QE

AH@CAl|QGAxyHCkkHC@

CCFCtO~AbkCwAxyHHTC@kCA

hHC@kCA]OC

KBkzG

bXleA@NBwI|APH

al]BvB

`eHCxyHAhH

LfH@^AbaXl~UA`eC

EBkG

HgDAhHg|ANiJg|AxyHY

gAhHg|ANWUmg|C

QBhgAG

]ABUmeL]IAHa~

h`AHg@wHAuhw~a

A~|HBzC

89

G`

S

`OHqj@Lk

bA]LkAHyv

A]LkAHyNHRA]LkAHN

XzAHAFTwvb@WRPNqC

{bAPYXUtO`[A]

P`[{XPP[AyN@C

UkkAoXSG

@B`YXjPOuG

]a[MzLD|Xx

ao^B

msxn^Bam]msxnBmFmxn^Hja

_]m{Un^|RoA{qBlBH

s`APjNmBamMja_O

AiojW`UiApPBH

NE@PAXjPOuC

GBUYXEOjG

O~g_uaA]tYMPm

MsEA@

OUazyCoUDAqU]

aHBUaXlAiHo{U

MsbC]]UsbA

]AazC

TBjPNGG

GH`FsBAPSsP

jNm]mxnBm{xnB

pPA@oAw

90

A

AoOMsb@CuOAb

UAqJNBYBMmWA@AXl

mKB@BBMBlBB_l~wBA@h

AHJApGAwQKbWA

@h~Ao@|AWWX{WAX

jGWLLaC

|BD|G

@HhPDXHAoXH{

\wkWAN|X{keUPDgAHP@D

\wkDHAL|geDAAC

B`vqavTG

sq|

pqAqah^A]o

azAyahHpAqA~}Coaz

]]UFhvTA{bJH@J

AwA]gw^AQg|A]

~hHg|wmC

BjaPdTG

NaE\AEBnOqA

aBBFWUAHLoqOHPCO

_johYdTAbaXWAjv

XWAjB~BBXFbXWAS@jB

BBB~XAiHX_zL@S@XA[j

aPPwC

CBxWUvTG

NazmACqtaf~AP@@Q@A

ZjLQX@~AzjvTxWCWA]

XFb

91

Fv]AA_FPjyAo}FPx

WysCgQh~APxWvXA

{b~W

AahxyHklBTB~

@AbyX]hxyHXCoH

xWvTC

KB`D``BzG

bDb~aA{i

M`AO\J|C]Ajhb~

WfwAYulAqXlBJ{AHJhCo

tBzb~aDGAP@

Yh_AN`C

EBY

uaOG

jHHHxAFi|FHaHxAF|AOH

ZAthApJA^UA

AH@@CAl@|QGFpJA^UkA

AHC@@CAl@|QEAotOAHYXv

HaOC

92

mG

B M

1. }B|AMQE~ZAm{xnAx_AXC

2. BlA

3. ]

1967AmsnAx_AXC

Bronislaw Malinowski^AAmNBPvnA

1978Au~OXC

4. G@HA 1979Am{nAx_APC

5. }

] Elvin Hatch^AQBGsA

1981AmHPznAx_A

aqC

6. A

1981AmHPnAx_AyC

7. yLA

1983AmxWa{UsinAx_AxWv

sC

8. a^A

1984Am{nAx_APC

9. UA

1986AuP|cvAmRUQ|nA

x_A_Be|C

119-130A

10. sme|A

1986Amsx

-TUnAAsFC

11. A

1990AuxWavAmUzMnA

195-230A

x_AFC

12. .^A

1990AmqUQ]IDnAx_AF|so

ie|C

13. LA

1991AmCqOnAx_AXC

14. \F]

Emile Durham^A

BA

1992AmvoA

] The Elementary Forms Of The Religion Life^nAx_AaXC

15. }A

1992Amx_]isnAx_Ax_F

C

93

16. A

1992AmUnAx_AC

17. sA

1993AmxnA{AHXC

18. AAQsA

1993AuHxjv

-S]

Victor W Turner^vAm

PnAx_AC

19. AqA

1994AmwBPHxnAx_A_mXC

20. LA

1994AmCqOgnAx_AXC

21. A

1994Am{nA{A|XC

22. qwA

1994Am`nAx_AC

23. _A

1994AmxbPnAx_AC

24. A

1994AuDPHRUvAmvPRUnA

181-242A

x_AFlsY|sC

25. pA

1994AuxDRvAmHu@

nA

163-186Ax_As|sC

26. Michael Quinn PattonAdB^A

1995AmPsnAx_A

a

27. Q]

B Morris^AizA

1996AmvHnAx_Ag

]C

28. qA

1996AmsknAx_AvjbC

29. Y}A

1996AuP[kvAmsGzBkgks

nAx_AyC

30. BJzA

1996Au@skWGHPHp

HpBnPRHvAmsGzBkgk

snAx_AyC

31. A

1996AmFHnAx_A~C

32. }A

1996AmxWnAxWAxWs||]C

33. psA

1997AmnA{AHXC

94

34. JQw

]

Clifford Geertz^AOA

1999Am

] The Interpretation Of Cultures^nAWAHXC

35. Danny L.jorgensenALBWA

1999AmP[knAx_A

C

36. BWuA 1999AuF

-lsvAmvoinA

5-28A A

s||]C

37. BWuA 1999Au

-EsvAmvoinA

172-218A A

s||]C

38. iA

2000Am @s@

-MH

nA A[BC

39. sFA

2000AmaqtdsnAAs||C

40. FA

2000Am Sw

HBvEds

-H^

P@t

nA A[BC

41. _tA

2000AuCqHyvAm

uCqoivvN

Q|

nA

247-257AA

sC

42. BWuA 2000AuHfp_sq|MvAmu

CqoivvNQ|

nA

300-305AA

sC

43. i~A

2000AuCq}ovzvAm

uCqoivvNQ

|

nA

270-279AA

sC

44. LA

2000AuvvAm

uCqoivvNQ|

nA

155-163AA

sC

45. SFHA

2000AubvWavAm

uCqoivv

NQ|

nA

306-308AA

sC

46. LEBHvwA

2000AuaBvB|PDvAm

u

CqoivvNQ|

nA

150-154AA

sC

47. FBmsA

2001Am{UnA{AHXC

48. s FA

2001AmEQsp|nAAs

95

FC

49. iA

2001AmjNUnAx_AzC

50. BaBsA

2002AmFmxnAAsFmC

51. A

2002AmlnAAXC

LBZ

1. EA

1985Au AD Van Gennep RzsvAs|

sZAQA

229-257Ax_C

2. LeA

1991uxWHvA~sqTAQA

13-18Ax

_C

3. bA

1992AuL`ufvxWv@[vA

xWZAQ|A

79-102Ax_C

4. ^A

1993AuxG@H|z{HXvAgz

sA@A

330-337Ax_C

5. iA

1993Au[GPuvAUAK

QGA

65-97Ax_C

6. fzFA

1994AuHvAUAEQA

147-191A

x_C

7. A

1994AuxWUh@cN

qvA

xAKA

32-53Ax_C

8. QA

1994Auqu@HaPQsYvAs

ZAA

18-26Ax_C

9. A

1996Au{N|HEPVvAZATQ@

A

33-34Ax_C

10. EA

1996AuP[P[[GHgP[

qP`vAxWjjHZAQ@A

59-73Ax_A

96

xWjC

11. ^A

1997AuPGgu@uvDvA

g

zsAKA

37-71Ax_C

12. iA

1997AuDMvAPATQA

233-292Ax_C

13. PA

1998Aupo{N|\vAQPAQT

A

18-21Ax_C

14. \A

1998AuBUPdvAPA@QTA

14-16Ax_C

15. BTA

1998AulhPdvAx_@z|

AA

105-119Ax_C

16. A

1999AuG@D`tz{HvAv

ZA@TQGA

36-41Ax_C

17. A

2000AuDUXz[vAunA|A

50-65A

x_C

18. A

2001Au\vAFdAA

183-206A

x_C

B

1. }A

1984AmxW`snAxWvdjs

hC

2. UA

1987AmHP~HRUsnApj

PshC

3. LA

1996AmUvQ{NNqnApj

vshC

4. ZA

1996Am|qLs

-HxWP

cEnAxWj|shC

97

 @

l ] p （ ）

F

l ] p （ ）

a p ]

k B p ]

k B p]

^

^

^

F

G

G

G

u

W （ ）

O

e

l

sM

M

l

N

~ y

98

F W]^

O

^

P

 G

XkB]ku

k @ u

k ] a u

F

F

^

W

k

F W

F

^

P

u

k

a

u

（

k

B ~

c ）

a

u

（

l

] ）

u

q

u

i

j

i

~ j

99

 T

a

]

X

k @

k

X

X X

k ]

k k

k

]

]

W

]

k B ~ c k B q l

F W

F

F

a u

]

q

i

j

i

~ j

100

 |

u

k @ ] k

t

^

a ~

@

~

iUj

101

] ~

u

u

F

k

F

~

u

u

u

q

u

p

a

u

l

a

u

iUj

102

r

]

m

X

O

X

s

p

103

Ba~m

~

~

G

}

G

O

_

~

O

s M

M

l

s M

M

s

104

hiC

@BXAQ}OVyAVy}hhWAjSOQ

@oXU~CC

GBXAWA^ANN}C

TBXAjSXlAXqAX

|BXAlrod]ld]NAdUor]C

BXA@@XHXWAijSa}

QdAiSQJ}]SWC

BXA@~TNl]AphAZNC

CBXAQubsAsuZnALBsC

KXAz@AJSpqYAjSoFCl

KBlC

EBXAjSjQ`QUAT~|~~iApF

nsC

QB

XAeOdAd}jAm]mH_C

@BWq^AQnXAUcQTvZ

LC

GBWBAQSWD\WAMj]]C

x^asC

QW

105

TBWdAq^}sAQMSWiwa

SOsC

|BWKAQMSnjH@PA~PLq

SnjH@NavC

BWASnFsAQMH~cs

RC

BW]AQiSHKAQjS

XTNl]C

CBWTAQqWSaiMBSAqhQn

Uu]C

KBWAQ_l\AijSsqWlA

iSQJq]SrC

EBWdAQiS@DQmsAF

QA]YSBsC

QBWAl]AAOwC

@BWqAQ@@HSASaWA]S

GBWNqAQY@}ATQYwAW

CC

TBWTAQWSaiBAnU\C

|BAQijS\AQA

SirC

BWBAQijSAhAijSaw

wCeAC

QW

IQC

106

BAQl\AijSsRlAi

SQJ]SrC

CBW^AQSWOAQ

AWQW\AijSsRgAiS

QJrC

KBWAQJQW]AQjSH

WOALHhQYxwbAQYu

C

EBWKAQQWSAQQj\QAijS

Q^YrC

QBWdAQijS@AQmsAF

QAYSyBsrC

@BXANAj]p]NA

rC

GBXAjSsNOBAP@A@n~

x~C

TBXTAMjSHt^jnABh

Bo|xrC

|BX|AjS|sAx}Nx[An_

wC

BXA~|BnAjS|@HdhrAOr

lWC

BXASaLl]r@NA@l

aWWySUS

QX

jUj

107

jC

CBXwAS^hXAS}TdAn~

qOMr

C

KBXjAlO]AE_tMqC

EBX@@AKWAZZAx]Q_Am_C

QBXFC

ABAl]W]BWlsWBC

AdAdQfUCC

AAl]AiC

A_Al]ioiC

AAA]DeQAA]^aieC

ANz@AA]AHNXC

AA]ioCUAA]

AA]KLV|uAA]XlqqNLANL}KKoA

oFClKBlqC

QnnlAeQfAdAjSpFn

sC

@B xMNAMN}hhWC

GB xA}KKoC

TB xQAQ}sC

|B xKAK}}|uC

B

xdAd}jC

n

Qx

108

M@C

B

xA}C

CB xA}WC

KB xA}oC

EB x_A_}C

QB xn

AndC

@B r@dC

GB rl]W]WlWBC

TB rWC

|B rQOwC

B

B

rl]loC

rxjNC

CB rl]Clnd]C

KB rl]KPoLC

EB rEC

QB rQgAl]]AByAl]qsC

@B xQsbomC

GB QC

TB [QsC

|B QdC

B

B

HQsMkC

Q~C

Qr

Qg

109

C

QJ

CB CPQC

KB ]QC

EB Q@@n

QB QgC

@B PQ

GB TA[e

TB Wd

|B dk

B

B

Lp

B

CB J

KB J

EB B

QB Ms

]EBkBBBsB][pBBE]^n^

@BWdA@bUBsA@gseA@O

sC

GBAlW~nAXJdAGod

C

TBWNyAQaz@AiLSSpYA

MjoFClKBlC

Qn]

1^

110

|BWA

RC

Bsk^aA@bUYAs

BW]AQiSHKAiSKPWA

TNl]C

BWBAQSWDWhACTxA

^aC

CBAAOwC

KBWdAqAQMSWwQdaA

SnwOQOsC

EBWKAQMSnjH@P~PLqA

SnjH@NaC

Q@BQWAS

BssC

Qn]

2^

@BnpdAMjSj@lhfAiwCUA

qhQJkBAkB@AqhQJnRV

pdrC

GBnp]AjSj{rTyi_AiQJk

BAnJQvXAqhQhFWnb

ABrC

TBn[AiSjAQA}UZoNAQ

knlaQC

|BnaAK}ASj@

hFWnHHF@RrC

BnpKASjw\ZLuFqAQ

lAqhQ

111

hFn@bgQqC

BnxASjl@AlaAqhQ

hFJNMrC

CBnp^AQikkJjAnAS

jLAQTvAZ~LrC

KBnpVA^rZw@UAiQJ

jAQnQQrC

EBnOAiP

aAkDQ{rEdA

Q@R^aC

QBnQPAQJ_Q]klAQsn

@AS~lPrC

QYSLSLASRUUASSRQ@C

QhWAWuj@hAqhkkJqHhC

Qh}kkJAkkJQdC

BAQikkJAQQbCoWiwA

kkJQQnrC

AQhfhh|bAfTvlAkMQ

hgWA@@C^rC

AQikkAikkjAqhQn

NwC

Aqh@QhFgW`}^OAkkJ^

q]

1^

q]

2^

112

arC

AQJ^YaQ__h@@AqhQJU

yaahAqhQJnyVCarC

PAHPA@qhQJrC

dAqhQJ}aSHwAaH

Yd AqhQJdXocSnrC

Ay\eAqhQJiaaa~aSA

LQJHrC

AH}afoqcaHT[jSdAqh

QJaHcqrC

BAjtXAqhQJkBkB@Aq

hQJH]Y@AdRajCrC

AwaAckB@AqhQ@Jq

FAkBdUy^aC

QYSLSLASRUUAS]SRQ

Qr@o@oAoRoASioAMkkJ

iQ@@SrC

QiSQsPaTIAiQJnoAiQ

JIa~PrC

QiSQa}XdAiQJ

C

QiSQioCUAiQJqWd

rC

QiSX@QLAiQJnAi

QJfhn]SWC

QiSjdiLAiQJdx

@C

113

WC

QiSVy}hhWAiQJ}SC

QijSjQa}dAiQJ~

]SrC

QiFSQsAiSQJPAhSUHC

QiSu]|AiSQJu]SC

QXFvbAMSQb@WAMnSC

QkaQjUjAQ}fnAjS

awC

QhFWAWuj@hAqhkkJqHhC

Qh}kkJAkkJQdC

QqhY@}AQsMuAqhQ}W

OOC

QOFn_AqhShiqhQ

L@@C

QijSanTAiQJjKa]Sn

rC

QQJt}ratHRARaH

QJAOOHrC

{bSFlxSLA{bSFlPP

QQSrC

@B q@AkQjjOCCAkRYA

RWAsqhASoAo]oSoWC

GBIAiFS]_AQLC

Q

114

TXlASAU

TBATAQhnh_^AMhFWA@@^aC

|BIYAqhQJQ|yAklFf

hA]QQ^ay\EYC

BIAqhQJIQ]AFfhA]

Q^ayl]C

BAiFQJSFASS]

]TXl]C

CBAqAjSQAnAiFSQJT

]zQeC

KBIAQj{jziFkkJAqhQhF

WAFkkJC

EBEAiFSQC

Q@B AqAMjSj]]C

@Boqa}}AKLV|uAWy]BoAj]oFCl

KBlC

GBodbAQj]oFClKBoUBAj]@

s

|ihAWyWNLC

TBoyiAj]o]WBAj]CsKihA

TN]XNC

|BoAw]pFnsAOwABD

wC

BoriA}j]]]aAQAj]]]BoAd

QfUCC

Qo

115

BoDAA]AkUNAA]A}C

CBoUACPAQi]wAqO\WAsFNQX

C

KBogqdAQFaonsAj]]NNodQfU

CC

EBo

AqAAQiowAiiongAkksij

C

Q@B oAsKALAnsyyeAsAkAj]

]~KeC

QIpJoSQb@qApJQH^anA

|FYA

OnGA

A

]^]^cW]^A

aq\yA

o]^YA

bbbA

OLcAA

PlbbeA

lSeA

QnlAeQfAdAl]pFnsA

l

nA@AqhyqoA

HjChUA@AaAq

116

hDA@PA@QAwbAS

@SFpAAp@Aqh@OdUyo

orAB@}~atAKuBAaHOyOtwA

AaHCnu]A@}OAB@Grh]A

@SA@]ObRnA@NQAqhk

JMQIwC

@B QQ_AQJMSQb@nAQJQ

b@WAM|AMSQb@WAqhkkJL

C

GBQQ_AQJ]QhYqAqhQ

JQvAYAnU_WqC

TBQQ_YL}hHAqhQbF@qofohn

[Wqh{sC

|BQ|Q_XsAqhQofohbA]OUWdA

QJQb@WACh[MSQb@WAn

j

dC

BQgQ_XQ@HA}RiAQJQb

@WAh}AMSQb@WnU}C

BQQ_YAQijSAFQQZ@A

MkkJSQb@WAQbAqhkkJ

Qb@WAnC

CBQQ_YAqhQb@WA]OHLLHAQ

JQb@WAd}QAMSQb@WAqhQ

QQ_

117

JnPaWC

KBQQ_XsAqhQbF@

WofohHQSWzAQ

JQb@WAXFvAMSQb@WAqhkk

JbYAMQJC

EBQQ_AQQJQ_Qqh]tqAQijS

X@HqAqhQiQJn}C

QW

@BWAQUqWSwzAQSfTAF

QAQQw]AJSSU]]A_

QJC

GBWLAQijjSQfAiS

QJD

dK]SFC

TBWdAQijSanTAiQJK

a]SnC

|BWAqhQhFsWAQ{jSHA

SbC

BWAYAQYSoAje{zC

BWAQTQSAQWLA

QJoC

CBWAQUeQJSWAHK_W

HNHWASQhgWC

KBWACiArWAiWJAW

EBW^AQnnFXQkiuAkJ_

Qo]C

C

118

QhW

QBW]AQoQJAQik]QWAik

]Qi|C

@BhWqAQJ_QhWlAQaWQ

YSoAj{zAYi{zAqhQn

yLKvOAyLKvrC

GBhWqdA_QQZqhQZWASioCUAi

SS]YlQ@F@@AqhQnRrC

TBh Wq^AqhQaWQSXYAqhQs

YADFY^rC

|BhWq^AQikkJjQi|AQ

aWAQLAQQn@C

BhWq_AjSQA@AKlnZC

BhWqQJQqh]AQaWAQn

DAMSQC

CBhWqKAQ@@HSKAQCKnT

KC

KBhWqAQ

aWQ]YWSwAQik

kJjAqhQ@O@HrC

EBhWqAqhQJ_Qqh]AQa

WQC

QBhWqhAQaWQAnQzAj

Qz@iXirC

119

@BO[YkkJQ|yA\M]A]\

EYC

GBOOAkkJQlAkkJFQA

YzC

TBOOAkA

wrC

|BOO^AkkJQva\yAQXF

zMSQnSFrC

BOAQhFWC|WAkkJ

QAOQrC

BOOfAQbF@WkkJdUyAMkk

JdA[drC

CBOOdAQvanAkkQAy

\zrC

KBOAQTCz~BAkk

MkkJSFQeSrC

EBOOqAkkJSFQHA@OHQ

AkkJeQWsNC

QBOOAQnCUnAHdrA

j]]Orl^C

@BieiAqhQJAkBye\eAkB@A

qhQJaHO~HOSFAHp

QO

dUyA]hFWi

JQPlA

Qi

120

QJz_rC

GBiAaBWiFQJi|AiFQJnAQ

JT

QSC

TBi}AQJfoqAadAKhqDC

|BiA]JY@AqQJhFalaCN

rC

BilAQJ}aNSh[AaaHeA

MMIyFQJ{zrC

BiSWxAaSwAfFAFyocSnrC

CBiCAaHyAHHRdHNAV`OeA

OrC

KBiHA~HQ@lqaAQJ@RARH

QaC

E BiUEyAqhQJ}kBAhtQQEhyAQJ

HHnnAHRnodC

QBiQAqhQQijSXCKihAXTNZC

@BWuWAqhQJ@kBAy\ayAp

kB@qhQJaa~aSHQJH

rC

GBWqqhQiSQJnAQJH@Qq

rC

TBWqQAQJjt}afqAkB@qh

QJ@Oc@qrC

QW

121

—FAH

|BWe

AqhQJHY@ApkB@Aqh

QJdRaijC

BWlrAqhQJ}aAaHeAI

yqhQJzrC

BWSWwAQJ}aSHSwAaYdAd

_yecSnrC

CBWq^AagyAqhQJ

@^C

KBWKAqhQJQhfhhAqhQJq

aH@QJ^erC

EBW@Aqh

QJkBYYA]_F

QJqHHnSnAqHRndrC

QBWO_AMQJ~cjAX_TNWRnjFAX

CKiA]XTNZrC

@BWqdMjSwzsAiQJjAqh

QQnRVdrC

GBWqJIqhQhfhhikkJjAnWsiQ

AMSjAKA\vhrC

TBWqqhQhfhhikkJjAn_l\

FAi

Sja}QQdAiQJjA

gQQ]SrC

|BWqqhQhfhhikkJjAnWsQ

NqhQ|BgrAMSjoax

QW

122

rC

BWqAQO~oQAQ_@MAqhQ

nd@C

BWqEAQQbQQAQi

QJv{Ia]PrC

CBWqCPAQikkJOaMdAiSjsv

W

AaC

KBWqAqhQhfhh|bAnyLKvOAyL

KvC

EBWqAqhQikJjAnKv|BL]iA

MSjOrArC

QBWfkAMQSX_TNWRnjAXCHiA

]XTNZvrC

@BqW@MAkkJQQAQdUy

kAqhQCeiwAqhkkJQ

nC

GBqWqGqhQiQJSQ

AiQJQQSWnrC

TBqWOb]AQfFCeiwAnHQAQjcA

n|BUnrC

|BqWAqhQikkJjAn[qW@Aqh

QijSWAdAiSQJAOC

BqWAQFkkJAOhAhFW

QW

zAijSa}d

123

C|WC

BqWqAQikkJjTQSA@@C

WLAiQJQorC

CBqWqC

PAQ@@hkhkhPAMqhkkJQ

nNwAkkJ@@Rkr

KBqWqAQhfhh|FAqhQikkJjA

nyLKvOAyLKvrC

EBqWqdAQJQM@@FkkJAkk

JQvanrC

QBqWGAqhQijSjQAi

QJ~SAQQ@@]SrC

sXUAQ}dAd}hhWAhh

sXAWA_AC

sXBAXXlSXBAXqhAXhgC

sXAodAld]NAdUoa]C

sXAX@@AiSdA}WC

sAN~xbAkNUAZNC

ssAiz@ApYAClKBlC

sXsAQusAsuZnALBsC

kXl

WnC

sLsASAj

jQjUApFnsC

sXsAeOdAd}jAsm]NNCC

124

 C

]

I

2001A 1-31^CQ

sqpTQjpqA]|mGQTAn@

dEQIKCCCqHnqB_qBFqBqBF

qqnjAq`pnNeFnEQE

IHWAKdhHf]~]sFA

AG@]wojqWAQMA

U

]I]wpC]AszLKqX

APUmtd]I~HKAHdeUm

]ICHUNjq|m]I@UORAHF{

]IUpC

BnmG

nmnq|pGAmn@@dsQ|IA

e`nTQIECm@QAHfdGQ

|HAeHfQEjAHfKFC|EQ@HAs

@jmA]OsFba]sFA

2001A 1-31^Cm

]IpUG

@BG

@yeqKs@ATs@Aeeq

TQCIAwQGAwvF|AvEQ

FeAe`eqQGIAwGQ@A

wvFQIGAv|QEIKC

GBG

125

m]@yAie`HpAuel

NNFMA]AsFw|Pnmi

WGAwEQG~usAgDC

TBl

]G

e]l]]IzAMAF]

DAmwiWC

LB_mG

_m_qQpGAmn@KEQ|IG|

Ae`nTQIG@Cm@AHf@dK

QHAeHfGQ@AHfKFCGsEHAbHf

WnmGjm]sFA

2001A 1-31^Cm]Ip

UG

@BG

@y`eq@dAmMepA

wm

Q@HAme@CQCHA`@wO@K

QKAwvFQKIKAvEQ@IGC

GBG

{@yA`eqpAweH|

QTyPHGQKyAwC

TBl]G

m]l]]IAbWC

126

FC@KQC

2001A

BFmG

FmFqBqHPpGAmn@|CQ

IE|Ae`nQIsKCm@AHf

KKQKHAeHfQIsTAHiK

HAOsHfTjmAnmP_m]sFA

1-31^Cm]IpUG

@BG

m]@yA@ee~A`eq@TQAw

AwvF@I|CAvEQKITC

GBG

{@yA`eqpAweH

QKyPHQTyA]wC

TBl]G

wbWl]]IC

vBmG

mFqBqHPpG

Amn@GQ

IKCAe`nQCICCm@AHf

KCQTHAeHfEIKAHiKFC@Q

HAOsHfm]sFA

@BG

@y]mFqAMepAu`

eqQAewQAwvFGQAv

CQC

GBG

2001A 1-31^Cm]IpUG

127

FqPqU]m@yHwAq`e

ipC

qwqAm

TBl]G

]ml]]C

128